What is life like with your car? Let us know and win £500 in John Lewis vouchers | No thanks
Car accident where other driver is trying to rip m - Pokermuffin

I recently had a minor car accident where I hit the rear bumper of a car in front of me. We were both stopped at a red light and I didn't realise that after I had stopped the car, it started moving again (like when you let go of the brake in an automatic car). This meant that it hit the car in front of me at something like 2mph (or thereabout).

Now I left some scratches on the car in front of me from my grill, which should be a simple repaint of the bumper (£200-£250). The other driver, however, sent me a repair bill of £1100, which included a completely new bumper, bumper beam, repaint, and labour cost. This is completely out of proportions.

If I was in any other car, I wouldn't even have left those scratch marks, but in my BMW 5 Series, the grill is sticking out a bit, so that left a few marks along the whole bumper.

I'm willing to pay him up to £300 for a repaint and the inconvenience but definitely not £1100. What shall I do?

Car accident where other driver is trying to rip m - daveyjp
Isn't this what insurance is for?
Car accident where other driver is trying to rip m - craig-pd130

Did you declare the bump to the police or your insurer?

Unfortunately, you hit them, there's nothing you can do. My son had a similar situation in which the driver of the car was fine about the minor bump, but it was a company-owned car (a 13-plate Insignia) and the company claimed that the damage after a 3mph kiss of bumpers was over £1,000.

I saw the photos of the marks on the other car (taken by my son) and it would have buffed out with some T-Cut, the bumper plastic wasn't deformed.

You'll just have to pay or claim on your insurance, I'm afraid.

Edited by craig-pd130 on 09/08/2019 at 17:03

Car accident where other driver is trying to rip m - gordonbennet

That claim for £1100 will seem frugal if you refuse and the claimant goes to an accident management shark, when the very first thing they''ll do is stick him in a new smart credit hire car for a few weeks while the matter ferments.

Agree with the others, this is one of those cases where you'll just have to let your insurer deal with it.

That £250 you assumed doesn't include putting the third party in a suitable hire car whilst theirs is being repaired, were you planning to hire him a suitable equivalent car for the period, including collecting/delivering both his and the hire car from door to door?

Car accident where other driver is trying to rip m - Galaxy

Yes, report the accident to your insurance company and let them sort it out.

That's what you pay them for!

Car accident where other driver is trying to rip m - argybargy

My wife learned a lesson about the sharks you meet on the road a few years back.

Just weeks after she passed her test, she was waiting to turn right at a set of traffic lights and a taxi driver going straight on from the opposite direction flashed his main beam at her. She made the usual (incorrect) assumption and started her right turn, whereupon he took off like a rocket and struck her car's back end a glancing blow. Hardly a scratch on my wife's motor, but his nearside front light cluster and wing was toast. He came back to our house with her to get the insurance details, and a few days later we received a terse,almost threatening letter from his solicitor, giving details of the claim he'd be making against her, which included use of a hire car to allow him to conitnue plying his taxi trade. We passed the letter to her insurer without responding, of course.

Given the amount of damage to his car, a Sierra, and the tiny blemish that the incident left on her car, an Escort Mk 2, I reckon he had previous damage and was looking to manufacture a claim to get that damage paid for; hence "flashing" her then making sure there was a collision. We saw him a few weeks later, driving, not a hire car but the same car with the same damage and clearly operating as a taxi. But we'd given it to the insurers and didn't feel at the time that it was our place to question the claim.

Car accident where other driver is trying to rip m - John F

Whatever happened to loss adjusters? Seems to cynical me that insurance companies collude, agreeing ever larger repair and ever longer hire bills to boost their figures.....figures provided by you and me. Both parties will have a claim on their records, resulting in either future premium hike or erosion of no-claim discount. A few hundred notes to the injured party with no mention to either insurance company would probably result in a better outcome for both.

Car accident where other driver is trying to rip m - madf

Whatever happened to loss adjusters? Seems to cynical me that insurance companies collude, agreeing ever larger repair and ever longer hire bills to boost their figures.....figures provided by you and me. Both parties will have a claim on their records, resulting in either future premium hike or erosion of no-claim discount. A few hundred notes to the injured party with no mention to either insurance company would probably result in a better outcome for both.

Hire Loss Adjuster for case. Probably initial cost £250 to start..

Not worth the money on a £1k claim

Car accident where other driver is trying to rip m - gordonbennet

Both parties will have a claim on their records, resulting in either future premium hike or erosion of no-claim discount. A few hundred notes to the injured party with no mention to either insurance company would probably result in a better outcome for both.

Many years John my then wife hit a Capri on a roundabout, it was obviously her fault as she described it to me, minor damage, bent overrider on our LandCrab and slightly bent chrome bumper on the Capri...i called at the chaps house that same evening and offered to pay for the damage...the young driver's dad answered the door and we had an amiable chat with me apologising for my beligerent (thankfully ex) wife and i offered to pay for the damage, so pleased he was that someone was being straight that we shook hands and he said to forget it, if he couldn't straighten it he'd find another bumper and fit it himself.

The current honourable wifey reversed into a old chaps car in a car park, immediately apologised and told the fellow she would pay for repairs, few weeks later we had a lovely letter from him thanking her for the cheque she sent which covered the repair costs, a cheque he really never expected to appear, some £250 as i recall, her being straight had really struck a chord with him.

People like us are going the way of the dodo.

Car accident where other driver is trying to rip m - OceanMan

What Happened in the end?

Car accident where other driver is trying to rip m - alan1302

What Happened in the end?

It only started yesterday!

Car accident where other driver is trying to rip m - OceanMan

Sorry I was replying to argybargy

Car accident where other driver is trying to rip m - barney100

I believe if you hit someone from behind there is no defence.

Car accident where other driver is trying to rip m - FP

"I believe if you hit someone from behind there is no defence."

Depends. Often, yes, but not necessarily.

One version of the "crash-for-cash" scam involved the crim pulling in front of an unsuspecting driver and slamming on the brakes. In that scenario, it wasn't deemed the fault of the driver running into the back of the other.

Car accident where other driver is trying to rip m - John F

One version of the "crash-for-cash" scam involved the crim pulling in front of an unsuspecting driver and slamming on the brakes. In that scenario, it wasn't deemed the fault of the driver running into the back of the other.

Is that because they found the concealed switch disabling the brake lights?

Car accident where other driver is trying to rip m - gordonbennet

There used to be, and possibly still is, a dedicated hotline for crash for cash scam reporting, does anyone have the number and is it still an operation?

From what i read the police team dedicated to this wanted as pronto a phone call as possible, presumably camera footage, even if the victim managed to avoid the planned accident, would be most welcome.