What is life like with your car? Let us know and win £500 in John Lewis vouchers | No thanks
Should I take out a new insurance policy? - Lanny

Morning folks

So im off to pick up my new car today...yay!

I informed insurers that is got rid of old one and they gave me 14 days to replace it or they would cancel policy.

Im still within my 14 days so thought a change of vehicle would be more cost effective but they are wanting £50 admin fee paid up front if i change my vehicle over the phone, £35 if i do it via my online portal but sods law, it wont let me do it via my portal! They also told me that any additional premium may have to be paid upfront too although I MAY have the option to spread this over my remaining payments.

Im currently paying £72 a month for old car.

Ive done an online quote for the new car on a comparison site and the monthly payments are coming in at £48 a month. And my insurers are the cheapest ones along with Debhenams (the same price)

My insurers arent very clear on cancellation charges though so if i was to cancel this policy im not sure how much its going to cost and they couldn't tell me over the phone for some reason.

Any advice please? Im picking this car up at 10am so need to get covered to drive it back.

Should I take out a new insurance policy? - S40 Man

How long do you have left on your old policy?

Should I take out a new insurance policy? - Lanny

About 8 months but its ok now, ive sorted it.

It finally let me do it on my portal. Stupid bleeding thing lol.

It said i could pay £46 upfront, (£35 admin fee plus £11 additional premium) but then gave me the option to spread the £46 over thr remainder of my policy (something the advisor on the phone said i couldnt do)

Should I take out a new insurance policy? - Falkirk Bairn

£72/mth is a big premium - however, cancelling the policy could still cost you lots. Car insurance is an annual policy - you decided to pay monthly - the balance of the premium + credit / interest charges can mount up.

If you have a month or so to go then paying up is easy - 6 months to go is nigh on £430 due.

NCB is an annual discount - 5 years is maximum normally. If you are at 2.5 years then only 2 is allowable & you start again to get another 12 mth NCB.

The last new car I bought I got 7 days free insurance through the dealer & Swinton - they quoted for the new car but were 2 x the premium I was paying with my insurer - so I paid the £25 upgrade/admin charge.

Should I take out a new insurance policy? - Lanny

£72/mth is a big premium - however, cancelling the policy could still cost you lots. Car insurance is an annual policy - you decided to pay monthly - the balance of the premium + credit / interest charges can mount up.

Its £72 because im a new driver. Only passed my test 4 months ago. In all honesty I dont think its too bad. But i think my age possibly goes in my favour too. Im 37 with 3 kids 2 of which are under 16 (something insurers ask now when quoting so im guessing having kids under 16 makes them assume youe going to be a more careful driver?)

Should I take out a new insurance policy? - Surreydriver

I think you will find your insurers are checking childrens ages because they want to assess likely risk/additional business of other drivers (learners) being added to your policy as named drivers.......

Should I take out a new insurance policy? - gordonbennet

Its when you want to change a car, or move address, or alter the policy for some reason that you find out what sort of insurer you've landed yourself with.

You're probably better off staying put for the duration of this policy, plus another years NCD gained all being well.

When i get insurance quotes on the search sites, i go through the quotes until i find a company i feel comfortable to deal with (some are barge pole jobs), so far its worked out well and admin charges have been either none at all, waived, or in the £20 total region.

Don't forget others like Direct Line, who do not appear on the comparison sites, they were cheapest for me last year (matched by current insurer) and i might well swap to them this year if the quote is still reasonable.

Should I take out a new insurance policy? - Andrew-T

I'm no expert on the details of insurance, but it's always worth shopping around even when you are just renewing a policy, as premiums usually ratchet up and you have to claw them back down over the phone.

So you could just terminate the policy, and unless it is nearly expired anyway you should get a refund with an administrative deduction. If your insurers want £50 to change vehicle that makes it even more sensible to start a new one - new customers usually get a 'reduced' rate.

Should I take out a new insurance policy? - Ethan Edwards

Blimey that's pricey. One of the benefits of being old is cheaper insurance . I shop around every renewal.

Just changed one of our cars. Total extra premium cost from Saturday till end March 18.52 with no admin fee. Annual still under 290. That's part of shopping around. You dont just take the cheapest you look at the ancillary costs too. Much sportier vehicle too.

Edited by Ethan Edwards on 25/09/2018 at 14:16

Should I take out a new insurance policy? - Engineer Andy

A lot of the cards are stacked in favour of older, more experienced drivers. That being said, depending upon the exit fee, it may actually be cheaper to change to a new policy if the premium over the year is lower than the old one (as long as its comparable) including that fee.

I was lucky for my policy with esure that, as a long-standing customer, they actually don't charge me if I want the policy altered (probably only once per year/every few years tops), as they did when I changed with 16in OEM wheels to 15in (OEMs as well) when I needed to change one anyway and the tyres.

I even got a £15 reduction in the premium, not necessarily because of the downsizing of the wheels, but likely because premiums generally were cheaper when I told them about it, as they do vary depending upon the time of year, apparently (not just from one year to the next).

Probably worth a look if a sizeable annual discount can be had (make sure its not a cheap 'n' cheerful policy/firm, as its worth paying a bit more for a decent insurer), less so if the difference is under £50 annually.

As Ethan says, many firms give a low initial premium, back jack up the add-ons, raise the excess a LOT and/or exclude many things from claimable items/reasons. Some firms also have a reputation for unjustifiably squeezing clients down on claims where they end up an a much worse position even if the accident was not their fault.

Should I take out a new insurance policy? - Andrew-T

I even got a £15 reduction in the premium, not necessarily because of the downsizing of the wheels, but likely because premiums generally were cheaper when I told them about it, as they do vary depending upon the time of year, apparently (not just from one year to the next).

Andy, if that is the case, why hasn't it leaked out and everyone is renewing at the best time? Or have insurers done it to even out monthly demand?

Should I take out a new insurance policy? - Engineer Andy

I even got a £15 reduction in the premium, not necessarily because of the downsizing of the wheels, but likely because premiums generally were cheaper when I told them about it, as they do vary depending upon the time of year, apparently (not just from one year to the next).

Andy, if that is the case, why hasn't it leaked out and everyone is renewing at the best time? Or have insurers done it to even out monthly demand?

I suspect the lower prices coincide when demand for buying cars is at its lowest, so they are doing it to drum up trade, including advertising more 'offers' (sometimes via the screenscraper sites). My policy change was in May.

The problem is that to change mid-policy for most people would normally cost more (if you have to pay a penalty to do so an/or if the reduction isn't that great) and beisdes, most people can't be bothered, similar to change phone provider or their elec/gas utility firm.

Of course, a cheaper premium doesn't mean a better outcome, as you only REALLY get to know how good an insurer is when you make a claim.

Should I take out a new insurance policy? - Lanny

My other halfs been with Esure for a while now...theyve been fab, never a problem with them. And they price match too. When his insurance was up for renewal in August they quoted him more or less the same as he was paying for his last policy. But each year he always uses comparison sites to find a better deal. His quote came in with Esure as the best but only £34 a month. I made a note of quote ref number, rang Esure gave them the ref number and they price matched it.

Not sure if my insurers (Go Skippy) do the same but i dont think ill be using them next year anyway. Their customer services are a nightmare too....

Should I take out a new insurance policy? - Engineer Andy

My other halfs been with Esure for a while now...theyve been fab, never a problem with them. And they price match too. When his insurance was up for renewal in August they quoted him more or less the same as he was paying for his last policy. But each year he always uses comparison sites to find a better deal. His quote came in with Esure as the best but only £34 a month. I made a note of quote ref number, rang Esure gave them the ref number and they price matched it.

Not sure if my insurers (Go Skippy) do the same but i dont think ill be using them next year anyway. Their customer services are a nightmare too....

esure used to price match mine as well, for a while. Now that I'm a long-standing customer, they won't any more, though they are still in the top 10 (of about 100) of the prices from the screenscraper websites and do honour those prices - technically they shouldn't as they are for new customers to lure them in.

I think it's because they are generated online so saves them the expense of going through it all in double the time over the phone. I also find (for me at least) they offer a better overal deal because some other insurers with cheaper premiums include a higher compulsary excess (mine is none, £100 voluntary).