Firstly, sorry to hear about the problem but the dealer seems to be (quite rightly) taking it on the chin: as the fault happened only 2 months into your ownership then it's assumed to have been present or developing at the time or purchase.
In terms of a cause, it sounds to me like a one-off, unlucky failure - either a material fault, as you mentioned, or a related fault. With modern engine management and anti-knock sensors etc, it's extremely unlikely to have been a fuelling or ignition-related problem. We are so used to engines being ultra-reliable, it's easy to forget that catastrophic component failures like this can happen. Such failures are rare, but still possible.
One thing that can happen in high-output turbocharged engines (especially when they are tuned with higher boost, etc) is the piston ring gap can close up because of high combustion pressures and temperatures. If this happens, it puts big stresses on the piston and can crack it above the ring groove, or even cause chunks of the crown to break off. If the latter happens then the engine's internals will become shrapnel pretty quickly. Perhaps #2 cylinder had a piston ring with an end-gap that was too small, or carbon build-up jammed the ring.
|