What is life like with your car? Let us know and win £500 in John Lewis vouchers | No thanks
Need help in deciding a Crossover vehicle - Harish

Hi

I'm planning to go for a Crossover (CUV) vehicle in the range of £15K due to the fact that my parents are moving in with me. My requirements in the priority order:
  • (Budget: Max £15K, Diesel, Manual gearbox)
  • 1. Comfortable ride and spacious, especially the rear passenger seats (have to accommodate my 6 year old son and my parents)
  • 2. Low running costs as I'll be doing around 20K miles per annum (Mostly motorway miles)
  • 3. Technology kit (Bluetooth phone & music streaming, Parking sensors are a minimum). Not so keen on the SatNav as I'll be using my 6 inch Tomtom or my Google Maps in my 6-inch phone.
I dont require any off road capability / towing capability / roof rails, all I want is a little bit bigger car with high seating positions. So far I have short-listed Mazda CX-5 and Audi Q3, please provide any feedback regarding these models or any other alternatives that suit my requirements.
  1. 1. Mazda CX5 (2.2 Diesel with 148 BHP)
  2. 2. Audi Q3 (2.0 Diesel with 148BHP)
  3. 3. Hyundai ix35 (1.7 engine might be under powered for my daily driving)
  4. 4. Kia Sportage (1.7 engine might be under powered for my daily driving)
  5. 5. Nissan Qashqai / Renault Kadjar (1.5 engine might be under powered for my daily driving and the rear passenger space is very crammed)
In general I like Symmetrical vehicles so I'm not considering vehicles like Ford Kuga, Skoda Yeti, Citroen C4 Cactus, Honda CR-V, BMW X1 which are a bit odd shaped. If I find a CX5 or Q3 which is 3 years old and done less than 50K miles and is below £15K, shall I go for it? or do I need to consider any other things before proceeding? Any suggestions/rants welcome, thanks in advance

Edited by Harish on 04/02/2016 at 09:00

Need help in deciding a Crossover vehicle - slkfanboy

To be honest any of them will be fine, but the Qashqai is the best seller for a reason. The 1.5 engine will be more than fine on Motorway duty.

Need help in deciding a Crossover vehicle - xtrailman

I'm on my second CX-5.

Have a look at this site for opinions, link is to a new owner.

http://mazdacx5forums.co.uk/index.php?topic=326.msg2083#new

Need help in deciding a Crossover vehicle - Avant

If you see this, Xtrailman, are your CX-5s petrol or diesel? It would be useful for forum members if we could find out whether the well-documented problems with Mazda diesels are now a thing of the past.

I like the look of the CX-5: when I looked at the smaller CX-3, a spare wheel wasn't offered as an option and there seemed to be nowhere to put one. Is that the same with the CX-5?

Need help in deciding a Crossover vehicle - xtrailman

My last cx-5 did get oil rise, but not enough to concern me with low mileage, around 8mm above the maximum, but well clear of the X mark where its not advisable to be.

I also had problems with BT phone connecting which was sorted with a different phone.

Engine was great, but i had a recall for the brake vacuum pump which had to be changed due to i was told being out of tolerance. Still i lost confidence in my engine being problem free with it being a early car, some of which had premature cam wear, turbo failures, i don't think they was many but i wasn't going to keep it out of warranty.

Mazda still does well in the reliability surveys so other makes must be a lot worst, German cars especially don't appear to do well, with Merk being the best for engine reliability. I did consider an X1 but reports of lots of problems with the older model put me off amount other things.

Also considered a Tucson 182? auto, which i thought was a good drive, but the mags don't seem to rate it, it was the down market trim and the poor emmissions that put me of one (compared to mazda), full size alloy wheel and 5 year warranty was attractive, but not the price, and its a new car with new car possible problems.

CX-5 has at the moment excellent residuals, these have recently been increased by cap i believe, in fact i think its mentioned by HJ, as its unusual for that to happen.

So i got a great deal on another CX-5, both have been diesel, first one manual, my present my first ever auto. Downside of auto is its only 6 speed so its costing me around 3 to 4 mpg in fuel, i on 37mpg locally while the manual was on 41 to 43mpg doing the same short runs, on a long run off motorway i had around 55mpg a few times with the last car, but only if i didn't have a DPF burn.

I've got a full sized spare because i tow, this loses around 2" of boot height due to the packing, a spare saver will fit level, but its a eye watering price to buy as an option, you might as well buy a full set of winter wheels.

Another link here going back to the first CX-5 on the road.

http://www.mazdas247.com/forum/showthread.php?123817748-How-many-Brits-Fancy-a-cuppa

Edited by xtrailman on 04/02/2016 at 15:30

Need help in deciding a Crossover vehicle - Harish

Just an update: I have bought the Hyundai ix35 S BlueDrive 1.7 Diesel Manual over the weekend. It was pre-registered with 10 miles on it and I got it for £12900. Overall I'm happy with the vehicle.

Thanks again for the replies.

Need help in deciding a Crossover vehicle - Avant

Thanks for coming back to us and letting us know. That looks like a good deal: enjoy the car!

Need help in deciding a Crossover vehicle - gordonbennet

That sounds a bargain Harish, i note from your first post you had possible concerns about power, same engine in the i40 i've seen decently fast and constant acceleration from those, can't see the MPV being much heavier.

Edited by gordonbennet on 15/02/2016 at 09:50

Need help in deciding a Crossover vehicle - Harish

Yeah, you can feel a bit of grumpiness in 1st and 2nd gears but once you are in 3rd gear its flowing. Anyways I'm not thrashing the engine as its new so will update once it completes at least 1000 miles. But the engine is very quiet and the ride is very comfortable.

Need help in deciding a Crossover vehicle - Warning

Diesel seem a great idea for people who do a lot of miles and even on car tax, but somehow feel the autorities will crack down on diesel in city centres.