"Why do people buy these cars..."
They don't buy them, their employers do
By reducing their salary, it's part of their employment package - taxed as such by HMRC.
I'm retired, no comapny pension for me but I've just spend £50k of my own money on a big 4x4 SUV - so that I can enjoy luxury getting to off-road places that no "normal" car could.
Each to their own.
Edited by RT on 30/10/2015 at 13:03
|
t I've just spend £50k of my own money on a big 4x4 SUV
Owner's review then, RT?
|
t I've just spend £50k of my own money on a big 4x4 SUV
Owner's review then, RT?
VW Touareg SE - too soon for detail, still running it in and haven't been off-road yet - but very well put together, spacious, luxurious and very smooth ride with air suspension and dampers set to comfort - like most modern cars too many computers but that's me being old-fashioned.
Compared to the Hyundai Santa Fe which preceded it, much better in all respects - which might be expected given the price difference but internet brokers can supply the base Touareg under £32k which is less than the top Santa Fe price.
|
|
|
I can enjoy luxury getting to off-road places that no "normal" car could.
Yeah Ive seen a lot like that. Usually parked inches in front of the shop/bank/whatever entrance, but thats only because they couldnt actually drive through into the shop, presumably the door was too small.
|
I can enjoy luxury getting to off-road places that no "normal" car could.
Yeah Ive seen a lot like that. Usually parked inches in front of the shop/bank/whatever entrance, but thats only because they couldnt actually drive through into the shop, presumably the door was too small.
...or a few yards into the school playing field for a car boot sale - that's as far as most 4x4s ever go, and to be honest, with the sort of bling-bling tyres many come with as standard, can go. To many big 4x4 vehicle drivers, the pavement also becomes part of the road when parking.
|
Its funny how this attitude changes once snow drops and you are wanting a tow out of a ditch etc.
|
Its funny how this attitude changes once snow drops and you are wanting a tow out of a ditch etc.
I doubt a Porsche Cayenne (or any other Chelsea tractor) would be that good in real snow and ice with their low profile performance road tyres.
|
Its funny how this attitude changes once snow drops and you are wanting a tow out of a ditch etc.
I doubt a Porsche Cayenne (or any other Chelsea tractor) would be that good in real snow and ice with their low profile performance road tyres.
Subarus do ok - often towing my bigger vehicles out of harm's way.
Stereotyping can be applied to anything good or bad, what's wrong with free choice.
I don't understand why anyone buys a car capable of more than 70 mph or with more than one seat as most cars are driven solo - I guess that's other people exercising their choice
|
Stereotyping can be applied to anything good or bad, what's wrong with free choice.
I don't understand why anyone buys a car capable of more than 70 mph or with more than one seat as most cars are driven solo - I guess that's other people exercising their choice
I'm not stereotyping, I'm just pointing out that a 4x4 with sports type road tyres is not going to be as capable in the snow as a 4x4 fitted with offroad type tyres.
There is nothing wrong with free choice but, there is something wrong when a person is driving a vehicle that is too big for her and forcing myself and others to mount the pavement because she can't drive with her nearside wheels being less than 1.5 metres from the kerb.
|
I agree, and to be honest, a standard car with winter tyres will normally fare much better than a 4x4 with low profile summer tyres (which the vast majority of them have) - even my old 1-litre Nissan Micra with its skinny tyres faired quite well during the 2003 snow-in (and on ther occasions) compared to most other cars, including one Audi A4 4x4 that was sliding all over the gaff (too much power for the low profile tyres to handle) - I even made it up (with little drama) a quite steep hill, whereas the Audi (and many other big cars) could not. Quite fun actually.
In my view people who actually want or need to regularly go off-road or live in rural/exposed areas which are subject to bad weather/snow in winter will not only buy a proper 4x4 (not pseudo ones like the BMW X3/5 or Audi Q series) with both off-road-capable tyres for winter and other times of the year. Those who buy the BMW/Audis and similar vehicles with summer tyres are, I think doing so to pose and show off (look at my wad - loadsamoney!) - quite a few people have commented over the years that some of these cars are alternative 'Johnson extensions' (I'm sure the alternative would've been ***'ed out) to the supercars of this world.
|
This is an odd thread.
So 35 years driving covering hundreds of thousands of miles. Suddenly when I buy an suv I apparently lose all the accumulated knowledge and experience?
Then I swap to our other car it all comes back again. Until I get back into the suv when oops there it all goes again.
That about what your saying?
Because I'm calling major BS on your thread. Does it sound like your thread peed me off? It did.
|
This is an odd thread.
<So 35 years driving covering hundreds of thousands of miles. Suddenly when I buy an suv I apparently lose all the accumulated knowledge and experience?>
why is it odd..
certainly seems that some people lose all perspective of driving when they are in an SUV or similar vehicle.
(Because I'm calling major BS on your thread. Does it sound like your thread peed me off? It did.)
Call it what you will, it dont change the facts, and they take up too much room in already congested roads, more especially those that need to learn how to steer them
|
This is an odd thread.
So 35 years driving covering hundreds of thousands of miles. Suddenly when I buy an suv I apparently lose all the accumulated knowledge and experience?
In all due respect, my mother has held a licence longer than you and she is an awful driver. However, she doesn't drive far from the kerb because she drives a normal (medium) size car and uses the front tyre as a measure of how close she is to the kerb (yes it's not a clever thing to do).
Then I swap to our other car it all comes back again. Until I get back into the suv when oops there it all goes again.
That about what your saying?
Who said that? I've no doubt at all that the person I refered to in the original post is not a confident driver in any car. Nobody mentioned changing cars has an effect on your ability. Many of my Collegues over the years have driven small cars and we drive pretty much the largest trucks on the road.
Because I'm calling major BS on your thread. Does it sound like your thread peed me off? It did.
It's a strange reaction, do you have any doubts about your own abilities? because otherwise I can't see why you'd react so badly?
|
My main point was that so many people who buy large psuedo 4x4s never have any intention of going off-road, hence the fashion/posing statement.
I have no problem in people buying luxury or sports vehicles, MPVs if they have large families or to fit in large amounts of work stuff on trips, estates are also very good at swallowing people and luggage/work things, but often large psuedo 4x4s are actually no larger inside than many MPVs/estates, plus so many of the 'poser' variety (e.g. the BMW X5 - commonly known as the 'drug-dealer's car of choice, second only in poser value [IMO] to the Range Rover Sport/Porsche Cayenne) have features that aren't suited to actual off-roading (so what's the point other than for the poser value?):
- 19in rims and ultra low-profile summer tyres capable of doing 200mph;
- Not full-on off-road gearbox features;
- Luxury leather/suede interiors [where do you put your muddy boots?] and;
- Engines that can only do less than a fifth of its top speed (limited to 155mph) off road, let alone on.
I've also noticed how many people driving these sort of cars (especially men) use them to 'bully' other road users out of the way, especially on dual carriageways/motorways.
|
It will soon, especially with the advent of electric motors, be as unacceptable to have only two driven wheels as it used to be to have only two braked wheels. Makers of large RWD cars now realise they have lost many sales in areas such as north USA and alpine regions where the climate and road conditions are not as benign as ours.
With much power, apart from less nimble handling, the dragster look is kid's-toy ludicrous with back wheels much wider than the front ones. Anything over 300hp really needs AWD otherwise the traction control ensures the hp hardly ever reaches the road if it's wet.
|
4wd is irrelevant in snow if you have summer tyres... as many drivers near us discover..
And teh person behind teh wheel and their driving skills can compensate for summer tyres and 2wd only, whilst some drivers with 4wd and all weather tyres can get stuck on a flat snowy road if they use too many revs at starting off..
Lots of 4wd drivers end up in ditches round here..
|
I don't think it helps that too many 4x4 drivers (sorry, most of them I see in this sub-category driver Audis and Porsche Cayennes) think they can use 100% of their car's performance in bad, weather, and especially snow and ice, 'just because' their car has 4WD.
Your right, madf, that driving skill - a light, smooth touch on the pedals, early anticipation of manouvres and awareness of other road users/pedestrians/surroundings is just as important as whether the vehicle has winter tyres, and more so than if it has 2 or 4WD.
|
I don't think it helps that too many 4x4 drivers (sorry, most of them I see in this sub-category driver Audis and Porsche Cayennes) think they can use 100% of their car's performance in bad, weather, and especially snow and ice, 'just because' their car has 4WD.
True, but a well made 4WD does help.....
www.youtube.com/watch?v=VAORFjO3cGI
........enjoy
|
Weekend story: Sunday pm.
Queues at roundabout near local Sainsbury.
Motorbike crashes on roundabout, (reason? don't know).. - cyclist on ground on roundabout inner lane - unconscious - so driver in Range Rover consciously drives past in outer lane scattering debris and preventing any help coming to unconscious biker's aid.
(May have been cause of crash - don't know).
Drives off , does not stop. Rest of traffic does to allow first aid..
|
May-be, but I wonder how many of the other cars were either RWD (no good in snow and ice without putting some serious weight in the boot to get reasonable traction) or just being plain badly driven? I've driven up 'hills' in snow and ice much steeper than that in both my old Nissan Micra and current Mazda3 without too many problems (without winter/all-season tyres either).
Yes, 4WD can help (all other things being equal), as long as the driver knows how to drive in snow and ice. I've seen plenty of 4WD vehicles in serious difficulty when I've been doing ok, the most likely (and common) causes being too much right foot and being in too low a gear.
|
Makers of large RWD cars now realise they have lost many sales in areas such as north USA and alpine regions where the climate and road conditions are not as benign as ours.
BMW and Merc sell bucket loads of cars in Alpine regions and the drivers have no issues simply because the fit the correct tyres.
Not noticed sales of Mercs and BMW's plumetting worldwide.
Summer tyres on a heavy 4x4 are a recipe for supper in a ditch.
|
Nice to know the jealous hatred of 4x4 drivers is still thriving.
Personally I don't think people should drive Audi A6 or A8's as it seems to make you drive like a tool. But then I remember we live in a democracy and we still have freedom of choice.
|
The problem with X5's Q7's RR's and the like is that they are often bought by road bullies, who use the size of the vehicle to force their way through without care or indication or any form of correct lane use, the ignorant in other words.
They are not alone in this, but as with lorry drivers who behave in this way they stand out like a sore thumb, gaining the name for themselves they wouldn't like (though care less) and unfortunately tarring those who don't behave like this but drive similar vehicles with the same brush.
It's part of the reason i'm sure why many drivers smile when they see such vehicles in difficult straits.
|
|
|
|