What is life like with your car? Let us know and win £500 in John Lewis vouchers | No thanks
BMW x1 2918 58k petrol 1.5 - Intermittent no heating - Redcar01

I have above bmw that I get my intermittently no heating or have to turn temp up to 24 to get a bit of heat , apart from taking to garage any ideas what it can be please or what I can do to diagnose the issue. The engine does not overheat and the temp stays in the middle. Coolant is ok have to top up a small amount between min an max sometimes.

Thanks

Edited by Redcar01 on 20/05/2024 at 13:36

BMW x1 2918 58k petrol 1.5 - Intermittent no heating - elekie&a/c doctor
Lots of reasons for no heat on these . Not much you can do yourself other than check the coolant level .
BMW x1 2918 58k petrol 1.5 - Intermittent no heating - Redcar01

will there be ant fault codes in the computer ?

BMW x1 2918 58k petrol 1.5 - Intermittent no heating - elekie&a/c doctor
Possibly, but you’re likely to need a good bit of kit that covers hvac system as well as engine.
BMW x1 2918 58k petrol 1.5 - Intermittent no heating - Rerepo

I have above bmw that I get my intermittently no heating or have to turn temp up to 24 to get a bit of heat , apart from taking to garage any ideas what it can be please or what I can do to diagnose the issue. The engine does not overheat and the temp stays in the middle. Coolant is ok have to top up a small amount between min an max sometimes.

Thanks

This could get complicated....

It could be...

1. Problem with HVAC controller or air-mix flap servo motor (one or two motors depending on variant fitted).

2. Faulty temp sensor on heat exchanger.

3. Fault of electric water valve, or wiring to it etc.

4. Blocked heat exchanger.

With the engine hot and running (coolant above 80deg. C) set the heater to max temp and feel the pipes to the heat exchanger (matrix) and check their temp is at least 65 deg C. If they aren't then you have a flow problem. If they are hot enough but heater output is low then you likely have a problem with HVAC controller and/or mix flaps. Really you'd need a dealer or specialist to accurately diagnose and fix. Be prepared for some serious expenditure! Make sure you check coolant carefully. These 1.5L 3-cyl engines have started to get a reputation for head gasket failure..... Its a fully sealed cooling system and and should not lose any coolant - topping up should very very seldom be required...

Edited by Rerepo on 21/05/2024 at 02:58

BMW x1 2918 58k petrol 1.5 - Intermittent no heating - Redcar01
Thanks for the comprehensive post , luckily I have BMW extended warranty and as it looks like it should be covered as long as they can find what’s wrong, I have booked it into the dealership but a month wait for a loaner as it’s in the middle of nowhere. I will update when it’s been in.
BMW x1 2918 58k petrol 1.5 - Intermittent no heating - Redcar01

Actually not so intermittent as I can set it to 25 degrees and its only tepid heat , at least the garage should be able to diagnose unless it starts working again.

BMW x1 2918 58k petrol 1.5 - Intermittent no heating - elekie&a/c doctor
It’s the same engine as fitted to the Mini variants , so could be a problem with the heat management module.
BMW x1 2918 58k petrol 1.5 - Intermittent no heating - Redcar01

Has anybody got the procedure that BMW will do to diagnose the heat problems on my car please.

Thanks

BMW x1 2918 58k petrol 1.5 - Intermittent no heating - elekie&a/c doctor
In common with all manufacturers, they have a guided fault finding process , which will possibly start with a test on the battery . If it fails that test , then the fault finding procedure will not continue.
BMW x1 2918 58k petrol 1.5 - Intermittent no heating - Redcar01

Battery I less than 6 months old

BMW x1 2918 58k petrol 1.5 - Intermittent no heating - elekie&a/c doctor
Should be ok , provided it’s been coded to the car battery management system.
BMW x1 2918 58k petrol 1.5 - Intermittent no heating - Redcar01
It was coded to the car by the company that fitted it but how would that stop the heater from blowing hot air ?
Thanks
BMW x1 2918 58k petrol 1.5 - Intermittent no heating - elekie&a/c doctor
It wouldn’t stop the heater working, but part of the electrical fault diagnostic process , the battery is assessed first .
BMW x1 2918 58k petrol 1.5 - Intermittent no heating - Redcar01
I’m just wondering what will happen If it’s ok when I take it in to the garage
BMW x1 2918 58k petrol 1.5 - Intermittent no heating - Redcar01
If I have had an old leak will it show up where it’s leaking as 18 months ago I had to put in half a litre and topped up every now and again with 50ml from just below min to top to max
BMW x1 2918 58k petrol 1.5 - Intermittent no heating - Fixed - Redcar01

So I ended up taking it to BMW who diagnosed and replaced the heater box so hopefully all sorted.

BMW x1 2918 58k petrol 1.5 - Intermittent no heating - Fixed - elekie&a/c doctor
Hope it was under warranty. That’s a massive job .
BMW x1 2918 58k petrol 1.5 - Intermittent no heating - Fixed - Redcar01

Yes I have BMW Extended Warranty so it just cost my excess , luckily or I wouldn't have had it fixed.

Edited by Redcar01 on 28/06/2024 at 23:35