What is life like with your car? Let us know and win £500 in John Lewis vouchers | No thanks
Spare tyre - primus 1

Hi, I have offered a work colleague a spare wheel and tyre for her fiesta, her wheel/ tyres are

195/55R15 , the wheel/ tyre I’m offering her is 175/65R14, would this be ok as an emergency spare ,

thanks

Spare tyre - elekie&a/c doctor
If the wheel fits the car , then it would work as a very temporary emergency spare . However , if the car has abs brakes, then I suspect there could be a problem with the system not recognising different wheel aspect .
Spare tyre - primus 1

The car in question is a 14 reg fiesta, so I would imagine it has abs, so I’m assuming it can’t be used...

Spare tyre - elekie&a/c doctor
It will definitely have abs , and possibly Tpms system , so no good for this car . Is there no spare wheel on this car or space saver wheel ?
Spare tyre - primus 1

No, it just has the inflation kit, I don’t have a fiesta anymore so I thought I would give the spare I bought for that ( not sure it would’ve fit that one either, but luckily, I never had to find out) , but I don’t want her to have it if it’s not going to be safe...

Spare tyre - elekie&a/c doctor
Best idea would be to buy a space saver wheel kit . Plenty on flea bay for around £60 . I wouldn’t want to trust a can of puff .
Spare tyre - primus 1
Best idea would be to buy a space saver wheel kit . Plenty on flea bay for around £60 . I wouldn’t want to trust a can of puff .

Yes, but that’s not my call, I just offered it to her as I no longer have use for it

but thanks for your help??

Spare tyre - skidpan

If the wheel fits the car , then it would work as a very temporary emergency spare . However , if the car has abs brakes, then I suspect there could be a problem with the system not recognising different wheel aspect

Had several cars with ABS and TPMS that have an emergency spare (factory standard) of a different circumference and not had an issue. TPMS valves are not fitted to the spare and if its ABS based TPMS a simple reset via the menu will recalibrate it if you want to put the light out. I presume the fact that all the cars we have owned have required the owner to fit the temp spare on the rear may have something to do with ABS but again never had an issue with the brakes or had a warning come up. Since all cars have had ABS as standard by law for many years if it was an issue they would not use space savers.

Most factory fit space savers are different circumference so I do not see and issue if it actually clears the brakes and bolts onto the hub. Just remember you are limited to 50 mph.

Spare tyre - primus 1

Thanks, this isn’t a space saver it’s full size, although it does have an 80 kmh sticker on it

Spare tyre - skidpan

Thanks, this isn’t a space saver it’s full size, although it does have an 80 kmh sticker on it

A space saver is one of those tyres that looks like it belongs on a wheelbarrow.

An emergency spare is normally a proper tyre on a proper wheel but not the same as the other 4. The circumference will be close enough not top matter. The Fabia and Superb ahve those.

Yours might be full size on yours but if your friends car has different sized wheels/tyres it would be classed as an emergency spare and again be limited to 50mph.

Spare tyre - edlithgow

I presume the fact that all the cars we have owned have required the owner to fit the temp spare on the rear may have something to do with ABS but again never had an issue with the brakes or had a warning come up.

I've managed to avoid owning an ABS-equipped car so far, so no experience, but I'd think it would operate on the rear wheels as well.

Perhaps this requirement is to avoid stress on the differential, since FWD is much commoner, and spacesaver on the rear avoids having your driven wheels with different circumference.

If this is the case, the recommendation might be different for the rarer RWD cars, if these have spacesavers

Spare tyre - jc2
I'd rather have two identical tyres on the front for both acceleration and deceleration!
Spare tyre - edlithgow
I'd rather have two identical tyres on the front for both acceleration and deceleration!

Dunno. The standard advice is “best-tyres-on-the-back”, but that’s not much of a guide for where to put mismatching tyres.

This site

https://www.drivingtests.co.nz/roadcode-questions/car/theory

says to put it on the back for both FWD and RWD unless you have a limited slip differential, though the stated reason

:this is because the front of the car is used for steering, braking and acceleration and therefore it needs the best rubber at the front. taken literally, directly contradicts the standard best-tyres-on-the-back advice.

They also say “Never fit more than one space saver to a vehicle”. You aren’t very likely to have more than one space-saver, but if you did it would seem to get you around the mismatch problem, and in that case they should probably go on the front. I’d doubt the consequences of that would be too severe unless you are a really major idiot or very unlucky

Here’s what happens when you fit four space-savers to a high-performance vehicle and chuck it around a bit.

www.youtube.com/watch?v=HPh90yNX-mY

(Everyone within a 25 mile radius dies, obviously, but apart from that…no real problem)