Thanks for all the responses, i didn't quite expect so many in so short a time. Places like these are amazing, even if some of the advice is not always reliable it can't be worse than basically gambling on my own inexperience.
I am suprised at the general disdain for Diesel engines however. (Unless you guys are talking about very specific engines) I was always under the impression they were more robust & were suited better to long distance coasting & migh mileage. I expected to be mainly recommended Diesel cars & to be honest, before now, have been looking more in to deisels than petrols for the above reasons.
---
ROBJP
Hate to burst your bubble, but VWs are very much trading on the old advertising slogan "If only everything in the world was as reliable as a ...". They've been pretty bad since about 2005/06, when they introduced their 'new' engines and DSG gearboxes.
No problem, I'm not specifically looking for a Golf, just a few people have recommended them to me, that coupled with the fact they're advertised heavily as reliable cars. Just wanted to confirm if the fact they were generally more expensive than other makes/models with similar mileage/age was justified
---
GORDONBENNET
If you have a tame mechanic friend who would come and inspect the right car before you actually hand over the cash (and look after it once its yours), and seeing as you don't care about image, you could buy very well privately, buy not looking for any particular make or model, just scanning whats conveniet, something will pop out that had the right previous (mature cared for) ownership.
Ebay is no different to any sales site, its reasonably priced media for selling things, no more sharks lurking there than any other places, but no sales site is 100% inhabited by fine British gentlemen plucked from history who's word is their bond.
Worth checking out Autotrader's version of HPi checks, i believe you can have 5 checks for £25, these are thorough involving finance etc and you do get some sort of insurance cover so long as you finally enter and confirm the chassis number before buying the car....
...Seeing as you're house saving, this lower budget is where i'd be headed.
Besides a mate who is a keen 'boy racer/chavvy' type, i don't really know anyone car savvy, even then he often sais big words but i get the impression he's chatting b******s most of the time. Hence my reliance on an online forum for advice. I'll open up to using ebay & i'll certainly use the autotrader HPi checker if i buy privately. If it has no expiry, having 5 checks could be helpful later down the line as my mother had a RTA recently & will be looking herself for a car when the dust has settles.
Also I think you may be right with a lower budget car being a better option. (Not that i'm ruling out something more expensive) Part of me wants to pay more because the last 3 cars i had under £1000 have caused me varying degrees of burden in random occuring faults & i'm thinking maybe spending more will make that kind of problem less likely to occur. But i know that spending more on a car may not stop random faults from occuring, wishful thinking i s'pose.
---
SL076
Auto Trader #DrivenByMe www.autotrader.co.uk/classified/advert/20170208211...3 Auto Trader #DrivenByMe www.autotrader.co.uk/classified/advert/20170202191...1 Auto Trader #DrivenByMe www.autotrader.co.uk/classified/advert/20170125163...4 Auto Trader #DrivenByMe www.autotrader.co.uk/classified/advert/20170205200...0
Thank you for the recommendations, while i like the look of the Mazda more the Civic has been mentioned many many times in this thread. the last one you mentioned looks very promising. If i can't find a suitable budget car, that will likely be top of my list.
---
ANDREW-T
The question you can most usefully ask is Why is the car for sale? Most dealers won't know this, and they may be unwilling to tell you anyway. Private sellers should do, and if they are also reluctant, try another. The point is that although some makes are statistically more likely to give trouble, you are only buying one car, and you may be lucky (quite likely) or not with any of them. Look for a good service history and signs of having been looked after, rather than heavily valeted in the last few weeks.
If i ask that in a dealers, wouldnt they just say they're dealers & it's there jobs to sell cars? Asking a private seller why they're selling is repeatedly mentioned in advice online so that ones already on the list.
In regards for what to look for, is there anything to look out for that an idiot could see. Online reccomends i check dipstick for milky colouring in the oil (something to do with a head gasket) wear on the pedals & misalignmen on the body of the car & Judging by some replies here a shiny steering wheel & bad wear to the gear stick gaiter also indicates neglect & of course good service history. That said how beneficial this information is when its me looking for these things is yet to be determined.
---
GORDONBENNET
In some ways this is why i tend to advise, especially here where our OP is saving for a gaff, to only spend as little as possible on as well cared for as possible unfashionable car used and looked after by mature previous one or two owners, if he spends £800 on a Corolla and gets two years out of it he can only lose £800 plus running costs.
If he spends £5k on the wrong car and in 6 months time some too clever by half gearbox goes pop and needs £4k spending on it he's lost big time and has to start from scratch again.
Sorry if i've waffled on too long again, but i believe if you offer some advice then it should be to point the person where their bets are best hedged, but thats only my humble opinion and everyone else's is just as valid
Don't worry about lengthy posts, i'm trying to get all the information i can before i go out & spend part of my deposit money. I've never spent £5000 on anything before & i'm certainly not going to p*** it away because the wheels are shiny. The deposit for the house is my priority by a mile & spending several thousands of that on a car only for something equally expensive to go wrong is a galling prospect. Just trying to narrow my odds. But i am convinced buying something cheaper may be a safer bet for me, even if it does reduce the pool of cars available.
Pukka Yaris in Bedfordshire with the right histories, i reckon it would suit our OP down to the ground.
ebay 182451754675
the only thing in its MOT history is 'fluctuating brake' osf, which i reckon means it might need a set of new discs/pads at some point, nothing else bar a wiper blade on any MOT
Bedfordshire is quite a way away from me. Would it be worth travelling 125 miles to take a look at the car. (Would it be worth comitting to buy without looking at it first?) How do you know it's MOT history?
---
Thanks again everyone, even if i garner nothing more from here, you've all been a great help.
Edited by Keith Poke on 15/02/2017 at 20:40
|