What is life like with your car? Let us know and win £500 in John Lewis vouchers | No thanks
Company car choice conundrum?
I have had a promotion at work and been offered the choice of a company car or a car allowance of £350 per month. The stipulations are that the car must be a diesel (as my estimated yearly mileage is going to be around 30,000 mostly company miles) and be no higher than group 20 insurance.
Am I correct in thinking that the company car is the better option? I have test driven the new Ford Mondeo and the 2015 version of the Mazda 6 and was impressed by both, but unfortunately the 2.0 TDCi Mondeo is above group 20 insurance so i would have to settle for the 1.6 TDCi. The Mazda is group 19 for the lower powered 2.2 diesel manual. Is this a sensible choice and am I making the correct decision to opt for the company car rather than taking the allowance? My workings seem to suggest that I would only be paying £989 in the 20% tax band or £1979 in the 40% band plus personal fuel costs. Am I missing anything here as it seems a no brainer to opt for the company car. Are there any other cars that I should be considering that offer a similar level of space, performance and economy?
Am I correct in thinking that the company car is the better option? I have test driven the new Ford Mondeo and the 2015 version of the Mazda 6 and was impressed by both, but unfortunately the 2.0 TDCi Mondeo is above group 20 insurance so i would have to settle for the 1.6 TDCi. The Mazda is group 19 for the lower powered 2.2 diesel manual. Is this a sensible choice and am I making the correct decision to opt for the company car rather than taking the allowance? My workings seem to suggest that I would only be paying £989 in the 20% tax band or £1979 in the 40% band plus personal fuel costs. Am I missing anything here as it seems a no brainer to opt for the company car. Are there any other cars that I should be considering that offer a similar level of space, performance and economy?
Asked on 2 June 2015 by Simpo
Answered by
Honest John
You don't want to get involved in buying or leasing anything that after three years will have 90k miles on it and if it's a diesel will be on the verge of needing a new DPF and clutch, new turbo, new EGR, new or cleaned out DPF, plus all sorts of work on the AddBlue system or whatever it has to meet EU6. So make all of that someone else's problem and simply get something that's comfortable and hits you the least on BIK.
The lower powered Mazda 6 Skyactiv D is fine. I did 14k miles in one in a year. It's also very strong. But you may find you need to jack up the front of the driver's non adjustable seat squab a bit to lessen fatigue on long runs.
The lower powered Mazda 6 Skyactiv D is fine. I did 14k miles in one in a year. It's also very strong. But you may find you need to jack up the front of the driver's non adjustable seat squab a bit to lessen fatigue on long runs.
Everything you need to know about choosing and running your company car, from how much tax you'll pay to your rights.
Company Car GuideSimilar questions
I’m due to get a new company car (I currently have a Volkswagen Tiguan). I want something of a similar size and spec but I’m after one with a much lower benefit in kind (BIK) value as I'm being hammered...
I want a small to medium SUV as a company car but I would like the benefit in kind to be no more than £4000 per year. My mileage is approximately 15,000 per year and I need to fit a buggy in the boot....
My employer has given me a choice between a company car (Ford Focus 1.5TDCi Titanium) or an annual allowance of £3420. I do around 12k a year of which just under half is business mileage.
After doing...
Related models
.jpg?width=115&height=75&rmode=crop)
Nimble and agile handling. Spacious cabin is very well made. Huge improvements to refinement and steering from October 2016.
.JPG?width=115&height=75&rmode=crop)
Impressive quality and refinement. Rides well with keen handling. Very spacious and practical interior.
.jpg)
