What is life like with your car? Let us know and win £500 in John Lewis vouchers | No thanks
Cam belt failure at 83k miles - who's responsible for the repairs?
I own a 1999 Ford Fiesta and a local independent garage has serviced/MoT'd the car regularly from new and we've relied on their judgement as to what should be done. The car's cam belt was replaced by this local garage in 2004 at about 36K miles.
This belt failed this week at about 83K, having done about 47K in ten years.
Car otherwise in serviceable condition, but now likely beyond economic repair because of consequent cylinder head damage. Is this loss ours to bear or would it be reasonable to expect a contribution from the garage or Ford?
This belt failed this week at about 83K, having done about 47K in ten years.
Car otherwise in serviceable condition, but now likely beyond economic repair because of consequent cylinder head damage. Is this loss ours to bear or would it be reasonable to expect a contribution from the garage or Ford?
Asked on 27 July 2014 by WS, Kent
Answered by
Honest John
Obviously not from Ford on a 15 year old car. That would be completely ridiculous. I think Ford gives the belt a life of 10 years and this belt snapped at 10 years, so why would either Ford or the garage be responsible anyway? I'd have changed it sooner, but that implies no liability on the garage.
Tags:
cam belts
technical issues
Looking for a garage you can trust? Honest John's Good Garage Guide has thousands of reader recommended garages, plus how-to guides and tips on servicing.
The Good Garage GuideSimilar questions
I have recently changed the harmonic balancer in my Volkswagen Passat 1.8 litre non turbo and had to remove the timing belt from the camshaft pulley - which was fine.
I aligned everything to its correct...
Can you tell me when I should replace the cam belt on my Audi TT? The dealership are advising it needs changing now as it is five years old - is this correct?
My Golf SE TDI Estate Mk 4 (2000), which I bought in 2013 for £800 and which has clocked up 71,000 miles, requires a new gearbox, mast, and cam belt. Should I go ahead with the repairs or not? Repairs...
.jpg)
