Should we replace our Mercedes-Benz E-Class with a Land Rover Evoque or a BMW 3 Series GT?

What is life like with your car? Let us know and win £500 in John Lewis vouchers | No thanks

Should we replace our Mercedes-Benz E-Class with a Land Rover Evoque or a BMW 3 Series GT?

I presently own a Mercedes-Benz E 220CDI Estate, but having moved to Suffolk my wife finds the car too low and wide for the local lanes, coupled with, due to our advancing years, we are keen on a high driving position with "armchair-like" seating. I was considering an Evoque or equivalent but noticed your recent comments on the BMW 3 Series Gran Turismo with winter tyres. What do you think?

Asked on 26 October 2013 by MD, Saxmundham,

Answered by Honest John

Road test and video here: www.honestjohn.co.uk/road-tests/bmw/bmw-318d-gran-.../ But I'd go for the 320d rather than the 318d, because it needs the extra torque, with the 8-speed auto if you prefer auto. Check with the wife first, though, because it's not much smaller than an E-Class.

Tags: automatics high seating position winter tyres

Similar questions

Why are there so few petrol automatic MPVs?

I'm a full time mum of two looking for an MPV with a high driving position, the option to convert to seven seats, and crucially an automatic gearbox as I spend time sitting in traffic. I have no need of...

Can you recommend an automatic car with a petrol engine and high driving position?

I feel it's time to replace my 2007 Volkswagen Golf Plus DSG diesel. I've been very happy with it but am considering a change. What would you recommend of a similar size in a petrol engine? It will be...

Can you recommend a replacement for our Honda CR-V?

We have a 2006 Honda CR-V Sport auto. It is costing too much to run as we only make very short trips in and around town. We are both in our arthritic eighties and are seeking a small car with ease of access...

Related models