I'd like to buy a Golf, but should I go for petrol or diesel and are the DSG automatics reliable?

What is life like with your car? Let us know and win £500 in John Lewis vouchers | No thanks

I'd like to buy a Golf, but should I go for petrol or diesel and are the DSG automatics reliable?

I want to change my 10-year-old BMW for a hatchback with automatic transmission such as the Golf or Focus. The Volkswagen dealer is trying to sell me a 2.0-litre diesel, but I would prefer the 1.4 TSI petrol. He claims that at 9000 miles per year the diesel would be the best buy. You have mentioned problems with DSGs. Are they less likely with a petrol engine? Are there any other alternatives to the above cars that would be more suitable? My wife and I are both 70 and I have a problem with my left ankle, hence the need for an automatic.

Asked on 5 October 2013 by AO, via email

Answered by Honest John

A Golf 2.0 TDI has the more robust, but high maintenance wet clutch 6-speed DSG. A Golf 1.6TDI or 1.4TSI has the less robust dry clutch 7-speed DSG. The Volkswagen dealer wants to be able to sell you a new EGR, new DPF, new timing belt as well as new DSG transmission fluid every few years.

Tags: automatics dpf petrol or diesel? egr valves reliability dsg

Similar questions

Should I buy a petrol or diesel car?

After selling my BMW 5-Series I'm thinking of returning to a Golf-sized car and was thinking about a 1.6TDI Match Mk6, however I'm wary about buying a diesel. We only did about 8000 miles per year in the...

Will it be more economical for me to run a petrol CR-V than my current diesel CR-V?

I am considering changing my 2009 diesel Honda CR-V for a new petrol CR-V. Is there an annual mileage limit whereby it makes it more economical to run a petrol rather than a diesel, and are there any other...

Can you recommend an economical car for my 60-mile commute?

I currently own a 2007 Aygo+, with three doors. Following a job change last year I am now commuting over 60 miles a day on the A5 and A38, both dual carriageways, between Tamworth and Derby. I am spending...

Related models

Ford Focus (2011 - 2014)

Refined and upmarket feel to the cabin. Comfortable and quiet on the move. More efficient petrol and diesel engines. Better ride quality. Excellent £750 Driver Assist Pack.