What do you think of Elon Musk? Have your say | No thanks

The cost of repairs to our 2006 Vauxhall Astra is spiralling - what should we do?

Having saved diligently for a few years my 22 yr old son finally bought himself, last October, a ‘decent’ car (Astra Diesel Hatch 1.9 CDTi 16V Sri 3 door - 2005) for about £7000 from a reputable garage. It has done 50,000 miles and last week it reported an error number. After taking to a local Vauxhall Garage it was found to be in need of a replacement intake manifold, swirl actuator and bracket - all amounting to £900. On collection from the garage he is now advised that the flywheel needs changing and at the same time a new clutch would be advisable – all at an extra cost of £1530! The cost is spiralling.

The car has a full service record (4) though only the first two were by Vauxhall dealer, the other two by local garages before he bought the car. He obviously needs to get the work done but before he embarks on this costly venture, any advice would be greatly appreciated as the short warranty from the garage he bought the car from ran out a few months ago. Do you feel that there would be any point in contacting Vauxhall directly?

Asked on 4 June 2010 by Mark R

Answered by Honest John
This is a nightmare engine with a long list of problems including those you mention, listed in car-by-car breakdown. Get rid of the car ASAP.
Similar questions
I have a 2007 Skoda Octavia 1.9 diesel estate with 82,000 miles on the clock and at the last MOT the garage said my DMF was showing signs of wear. There is a slight vibration on the clutch pedal. He told...
I purchased a Volkswagen Jetta from Car Giant, White City for £9,639 in March 2008. It had had one owner (Avis) and a very low mileage. Car Giant gave it a clean bill of health. I subsequently had it checked...
My wife has a 2005 Volkswagen Golf 2.0FSI GT with 51,000 on the clock. The light in the ESP switch, and the dashboard steering wheel and ABS signs, have all come on together, intermittently, over the last...
Related models
Sharp looks, comfortable motorway cruiser, responsive and economical engines, durable interior materials, lots on the second hand market.