What is life like with your car? Let us know and win £500 in John Lewis vouchers | No thanks

Buying a new tyre, but forced to buy a new wheel too - is this right?

I’ve just got yet another puncture on my 2005 Nissan Micra. The RAC came out and put the space saver wheel on for me so I can still drive around, and wrote down the “code” for the tyre so I would know what size tyre to ask for. However when I went to get a new tyre I was told I needed a new wheel as well.

This happens every time I need a new tyre and I’m getting very suspicious. I’m not technical and have very little knowledge, but I’m beginning to think the garages are taking advantage of this, as surely the idea of having tyres that detach from wheels is that you just replace the tyre?

Also, the front wheels and tyres were replaced only around 18 months ago and I’ve only done around 12,000 miles since then (on “normal” roads), so surely they should last longer than this?

Asked on 13 January 2014 by kittykatt

Answered by Honest John
The only reasons I can think of for you needing new wheels is either that you have damaged them so severely in potholes and against kerbs or that they are alloy and have become porous. I have never ever heard of a tyre fitter recommending new wheels as well as tyres unless this was the case, but if you are suspicious take the matter up with your local Trading Standards.
Similar questions
I own a Nissan Micra K-12 and I have a slight egg shaped bulge in the front wheel on the drivers side. I need to replace just this one tyre. The tyres are Continental 185/50R16 81, but I can only seem...
I have recently purchased a BMW 118d cabriolet on sensible 16-inch wheels with 205 55 16 tyres. These are not run flats but I do not trust the tyre repair and inflation kit to work and know that you have...
Can you tell me what the speed ratings mean on a set of tyres?
Related models
Cute looks. Not very different from the Fiat 500.
 

Value my car

Save £75 on Warranty using code HJ75

with MotorEasy

Get a warranty quote

Save 12% on GAP Insurance

Use HJ21 to save on an ALA policy

See offer