Should I go for a 1998 Mercedes-Benz 250 TD Classic or a 2000 BMW 5 Series?

What is life like with your car? Let us know and win £500 in John Lewis vouchers | No thanks

Should I go for a 1998 Mercedes-Benz 250 TD Classic or a 2000 BMW 5 Series?

I have a 1998 BMW 323i SE Touring but it's heavy on juice and my partner can't drive manuals yet. I have seen a 1998 Mercedes-Benz 250 TD Classic with 126,000 miles on the clock on Autotrader. Also, I have seen a 2000 BMW 530d with 160,000 on clock. Both are asking for £2000, both are automatics and are open to p/x, but although I have a BMW at moment I'm not sure if I should stay with BMW or go with the Merc. Can you throw some light on subject?

Asked on 28 May 2010 by jamie1904

Answered by David Ross

The BMW sounds like a good deal as the older Mercedes-Benz 250 diesel isn't a very smooth engine compared to the BMW 530d. The extra miles are unlikely to make a big difference on cars of this age and current mileage.

Tags: automatics fuel economy diesels mileage

Similar questions

Can I buy a diesel automatic crossover without fear of DPF problems?

I am about to retire and looking to buy a crossover, but am put off by all the dealers telling me I have to do at least 15,000 miles per year if I want a diesel. I do 10,000 miles. I also have driven automatics...

Would you recommend a 2006 KIA Sportage to drive from the UK to Portugal?

I'm thinking of buying a 2006 KIA Sportage automatic diesel (2-litre 4x4) with 49,000 miles on the clock, with a view to driving to Portugal from Dover. Is there anything I should look out for? Does this...

What do you think of the new diesel EDC automatic gearbox in the Renault Megane and Scenic?

I enjoy your reviews excellent. Renault have brought out a new 1.5 diesel EDC auto gearbox going into the Scenic and Megane. I would be interested in your thoughts, have you seen it? As I'm getting older...