What is life like with your car? Let us know and win £500 in John Lewis vouchers | No thanks

What do you think of the new diesel EDC automatic gearbox in the Renault Megane and Scenic?

I enjoy your reviews excellent. Renault have brought out a new 1.5 diesel EDC auto gearbox going into the Scenic and Megane. I would be interested in your thoughts, have you seen it? As I'm getting older I would like an automatic Scenic and, for economy, this is better than my 1.5 dci Scenic manual.

Asked on 14 June 2010 by David Coulter

Answered by David Ross
I've driven this engine and gearbox in the latest Megane hatchback and it's pretty good - although not as slick or as smooth as the similar DSG gearbox Volkswagen uses. It sometimes feels a little hesitant to change gear when you're driving quickly, but in everyday driving it's good enough. The best part is that it means low CO2 emissions and good fuel economy. In a family car like the Scenic it should work well.
Similar questions
Can you explain the workings of the EGC gearbox on the HDi 110 engine? The CO2 is only 130 vs 137 for the manual version (the HDi 163 that I originally favoured omits 173). Can one just leave it in automatic...
I need to replace my Volvo S80 and have been looking at the new, very fuel-efficient diesel engine cars (Blue Motion, Greenline, Volvo Drive-e etc). But the problems with DPFs and dual mass flywheels are...
I will soon need to replace my Volkswagen Golf 1.6 Auto, which will be 11 years old shortly and has over 120,000 miles on the clock. I would much appreciate your advice in choosing a similar sized, fully...
Related models
Comfortable for seven. Great chain-cam 1.4 TCe 130 engine. Brilliant new chain-cam 1.6 dCi 130 diesel engine from mid 2011.