Using mismatched tyres - safe?

I was running with a new set of Michelin Energy Saver+ tyres (done 3000 miles).

Unfortunately the sidewall ruptured on one of my tyres and the garage mentioned it was not repairable. Hence I had to replace it. Again unfortunate to not get the same tyre type and hence had to go in for a Primacy 3 tyre on the nearside rear tyre.

Is it safe to have different tyre models (Energy Saver + and Primacy 3) and tread patterns on the same axle though the specification is the same (205/55 R16 91V)?

Asked on 12 May 2013 by Vignesh

Answered by Honest John
Not ideal but not unsafe. Others have reported shortages of Energy Saver+.
Similar questions
I have recently purchased a BMW 118d cabriolet on sensible 16-inch wheels with 205 55 16 tyres. These are not run flats but I do not trust the tyre repair and inflation kit to work and know that you have...
Is one missing wheel nut now an MoT fail? On a similar subject, can you still have an MoT a month before and still use the car even if it fails (unless it's considered unroadworthy) or has that changed...
I just bought a Ford Tourneo Connect WAV but the ride is very bumpy. It has Continental Contact 2 tyres fitted - is there a softer tyre I could fit to make the ride more comfortable?