What is life like with your car? Let us know and win £500 in John Lewis vouchers | No thanks

The Phantom Splutter

I purchased a second hand 2008 (58) Mini One (petrol) two months ago from a private seller. Everything had been great for the first few days until the car started to cut out in first gear when I was waiting to pull out at a junction or island.

I took it to the approved MINI garage who told me that I had very little oil in the engine - they topped it up and for the next week everything was back to normal.

Ever since then I have been driving the car short distances to work and back but whenever I pull out at a junction, island or sit in a traffic jam the engine splutters as if it is going to cut out. There are varying degrees of spluttering, from just a small 'cough' to a full 'shudder'. I have taken the car back to the garage but they tell me that the car is perfectly fine.

However they told me the most likely problem would be my spark plugs but that they were working well. However they did put an additive into the car anyway so as to try to get rid of the problem by cleaning out the engine. This has not worked and in fact the spluttering is getting worse. It happens every time the engine is cold and it does not seem to be affected by outside temperatures.

I have taken the car for a long run to try to clear out the engine but the problem just returns the next day.

The garage says that there is no problem but both my father and I have witnessed the spluttering first hand and we both agree that there is something wrong with the car. I was wondering whether you may be able to provide me with an idea as to what it could be as I am worried that the engine will cut out completely on me at some point.

Asked on 11 May 2013 by H Alexander

Answered by Honest John
Try running it exclusively on Shell V-Power Nitro +. I think the problem is the short distances you are driving it, but the engine will not only self clean on V-Power it will run more cleanly at low revs while it is warming up.
Similar questions
My car can suddenly stall and engine cut out after driving half a mile. Try to restart it and the revs will not stay up to idle speed and the engine cuts again. If I rev the engine for a while and then...
We have a 2006 2.0-litre petrol automatic Peugeot 807. It runs well and when plugged into a diagnostic machine there are no faults or issues. However, on occasion the throttle is unresponsive from standing...
I have a repetitive problem with my 2002 Ford Mondeo 2.0 TDCi - the car stalls in cold weather It only happens for the first few hundred metres and only when I stop accelerating and it drops to idle...
 

Value my car

Save £75 on Warranty using code HJ75

with MotorEasy

Get a warranty quote

Save 12% on GAP Insurance

Use HJ21 to save on an ALA policy

See offer