Could you do a long range economy test on a hybrid vs a modern diesel?

What is life like with your car? Let us know and win £500 in John Lewis vouchers | No thanks

Could you do a long range economy test on a hybrid vs a modern diesel?

I love diesels as they suit the terrain here in southern Spain; lots of steep hills where you do not need to change to a lower gear to easily get up them, but we have to go with the flow I guess. I have a report from a UK newspaper about five years ago when a Prius and a BMW 520d travelled from Fleet St. to Geneva in one trip as a fuel consumption test. The BMW won easily and used less fuel than the Prius. It would be very interesting to repeat the test now with new cars. The Prius could be replaced with the Focus 3-cyl and the BMW 520d by a BMW 120d. Perhaps you could suggest it?

Asked on 17 November 2012 by BD, Malaga

Answered by Honest John

Not really a fair test. Hybrids are best in hilly areas or cities and suburbs. Diesels are best long distance because long distance a hybrid gets little chance to regenerate. Best I've done in one was 63mpg delivering my dad's Auris hybrid from London to Northumberland. He has averaged around 53mpg ever since. On the same run, on the car’s meter, a BMW 320dED apparently averaged more than 75mpg and I have averaged 65mpg in it ever since.

Tags: fuel economy hybrid diesels high mileage range

Similar questions

Eco worrier

I have just bought a 2004 manual BMW 320 diesel ES Tourer. I switched on the computer at the start of a run largely in 6th gear of 130 motorway miles. At the end I had done no better than 45mpg according...

Do hybrids perform well for high-mileage drivers?

My lease car is due for renewal through my NHS leasing scheme. At the moment, I have a diesel Kia Ce'ed, for which I pay £105 per month. Prices have increased and the same car will cost me £165 next time,...

I do 15,000 miles per year - should I buy a diesel or hybrid to get the best economy and least trouble?

I'm currently running a 2009 Volkswagen Golf Plus 2.0 TDI that I've had for almost five trouble-free years. It'll be at 90,000 miles soon and I think I should get out before I have to spend money on it....

Related models

BMW 5 Series (2010 - 2017)

Brilliant ride and handling, powerful and efficient diesel engines, upmarket interior, very safe, lots on the used market.

Ford Focus (2011 - 2014)

Refined and upmarket feel to the cabin. Comfortable and quiet on the move. More efficient petrol and diesel engines. Better ride quality. Excellent £750 Driver Assist Pack.