What is life like with your car? Let us know and win £500 in John Lewis vouchers | No thanks
Are diesel engines safer than petrol engines?
I've been following the diesel versus petrol debate, which seems to be concerned mainly with the overall costs. I've bought diesels for the last 25 years, preferring them for several reasons, not least being safety. I've twice got very close (though not involved, thank goodness) to accidents involving cars in flames, and been horrified. I once read that if the first cars had been diesel then petrol would have been banned when it was first invented due to safety concerns, because it ignites so much more easily. And I also read somewhere that committing suicide by running a hose from the exhaust won't work with a diesel engine because it doesn't produce enough carbon monoxide. I assume running the engine in a closed space might also be safer than with a petrol engine. What do you think?
Asked on 28 July 2012 by SW, Dunning
Answered by
Honest John
You can't top yourself with a petrol car either these days because the cat converter converts the CO into CO2. But you make a good point about compression ignition engines. Unfortunately the new downside is that all the emissions kit that diesels now have to carry hugely increases their cost and makes them unreliable after around three years.
Tags:
diesel engines
petrol engines
Similar questions
Are all cars with turbos problematic? I keep reading about turbo failures which puts me off buying a new car with a turbo. Do you have to treat these turbo cars in special ways, particularly after a long...
Any idea when the petrol Ingenium engine (252PS already in Jaguar F-Pace) will be launched for Land Rover Discovery Sport?
Can you provide the real mpg figure for a 2008 1.4 Volkswagen Golf and Golf Plus TSI SE DSG 5-door. The figures on the list don't distinguish between petrol and diesel.