What is life like with your car? Let us know and win £500 in John Lewis vouchers | No thanks
Is box junction enforcement being used as a cash cow?
I would suggest to RW that charges for stopping in a box junction are not just ‘a way to extort yet more money from the motorist’ but actually a national scandal in the making that will eventually lead to personal injury. For example, Brent Council in north-west London seems to have gone box junction crazy recently. At one in particular (East Lane junction with Llanover Road) I know of four motorists, including my wife and myself, who incurred £130 fines for stopping there. No doubt hundreds more have also incurred fines here.
As RW said the problem is that it really is not always easy to see far enough ahead to know if the traffic will flow over it properly. Presumably councils like Brent know this and realise what an easy way it is to make money. As more and more motorists get clobbered with disproportionately excessive fines at these box junctions then I believe they will start taking drastic, possibly dangerous action to avoid being caught: emergency stops before driving over them, sudden short bursts of acceleration to get through them and even driving into opposite lanes to circumvent them. This can surely only lead to more accidents, injuries and insurance claims. Nobody stops on these junctions deliberately but the punishment far outweighs the ‘crime.
Surely there needs to be a more considered approach to this kind of offence: perhaps an initial warning, then a first fine of just £10 doubling for each further offence committed over say, a three year period, after which they are struck from the record and you start again. A more lenient approach like this might make people think the approach is fair and genuinely aimed at improving road safety, rather than just raising revenue (apparently Brent has a huge pension deficit).
As RW said the problem is that it really is not always easy to see far enough ahead to know if the traffic will flow over it properly. Presumably councils like Brent know this and realise what an easy way it is to make money. As more and more motorists get clobbered with disproportionately excessive fines at these box junctions then I believe they will start taking drastic, possibly dangerous action to avoid being caught: emergency stops before driving over them, sudden short bursts of acceleration to get through them and even driving into opposite lanes to circumvent them. This can surely only lead to more accidents, injuries and insurance claims. Nobody stops on these junctions deliberately but the punishment far outweighs the ‘crime.
Surely there needs to be a more considered approach to this kind of offence: perhaps an initial warning, then a first fine of just £10 doubling for each further offence committed over say, a three year period, after which they are struck from the record and you start again. A more lenient approach like this might make people think the approach is fair and genuinely aimed at improving road safety, rather than just raising revenue (apparently Brent has a huge pension deficit).
Asked on 21 July 2012 by RW, Northwood
Answered by
Honest John
You are absolutely right. The over-enforcement of box junction rules can lead to gridlock. But the enforcer's argument is that failure to enforce these rules also leads to gridlock. Britain has ceased to be a fair-minded country. Penalty Culture was introduced during Gordon Brown's regime and it is now not only completely out of hand, it is big business. Members of the British Parking Association are estimated to rake in a total of around £160,000,000 a year. If 80 per cent of that is 'profit', then they have the financial strength to exert quite a lot of political influence. Not that Public Servants and MPs are in any way corrupt. Apparently only around 2.5 per cent of all transactions in the UK are corrupt, but don't ask me how honestly this figure is arrived at.
Tags:
Similar questions
I purchased a BMW X3 2019 model in Jan 2023 and it has developed issues with its brake discs. I have given the dealer four opportunities to repair but they have not been able to.
I have now rejected...
If I park on a wide pavement with double yellow lines painted on the road an I technically parking on double yellow lines?
My son parked his van on a wide pavement so wasn't blocking either the pavement...