What is life like with your car? Let us know and win £500 in John Lewis vouchers | No thanks

Please warn your readers that insurance companies will avoid paying claims if they can.

Recently, I helped my lady-pensioner cousin with a claim on her car insurance. She had been a customer for several years with Co-op Insurance Services (CIS), based in Manchester. She flew back from holiday in July 2010 to find that her car had been stolen from her driveway at home (though locked and with the keys inside her burglar-alarmed house). The car was found later, trashed and a write-off. It seems some kids may have done it for fun. Nobody has ever been prosecuted.

My cousin made a claim on CIS - and at first their inspector offered her £3000 in settlement. CIS then withdrew this, via their Loss Adjuster, a multi-national firm called Cunningham & Lindsay (C&L). This firm instanced the “facts” among others, that: the wrecked car had one possibly illegal tyre; there was no forcing damage to the car doorlock; my cousin at the time of renewal had not notified a fixed-penalty fine of £60 for inadvertently going through a red light, plus other irrelevant stuff. All done with photos and an aggressive letter style. Bluster, not substance.

We did not accept this - and neither did the Financial Services Ombudsman, who ruled in our favour, making CIS with the two years’ interest pay my cousin an eventual £3,891. But with truly professional tactics by C&L, the process took seven months, with CIS and their Loss Adjusters wriggling every inch, every second and every step of the way.

The lessons I would draw from this for every motorist out there are these: your insurance company, while loving your premium payment, may not be so keen on paying out on claims; they and their advisors may well reach for any pretext, however far-fetched, to deny your legitimate claim; they may well retain cynical, professional claim-deniers to conjure up a case against you - and these people are called ‘Loss Adjusters’, but whose loss are they adjusting? Yours.

Asked on 9 January 2012 by MS, Greenwich, SE10

Answered by Honest John
Most car insurers are now run as profit making enterprises by private equity funds. These are all the tactics of private equity firms. Or they are run as limited companies, in which case the directors’ principal legal responsibility is to show a profit to the shareholders. In the old days, car insurance was used as a loss leader by big insurance companies to get leads for other, more profitable insurance business. Not any more. From reader reports, the best insurer is currently LV (Liverpool Victoria), which is a mutual insurer and therefore operates to the mutual benefit of its policyholders. But beware. Equitable Life was also a mutual insurer.
Similar questions
I was involved in a car accident last year and the other party admitted liability. His insurance company rang and confirmed liability both to me and my insurers. My insurance duly paid for all the repairs...
My (almost) immaculate and reliable 2001 BMW 320i SE has been badly damaged by a driver who claimed he couldn't see me as he reversed. He has accepted full responsibility for the accident. My dealer says...
Please can you help me? At the end of last year I loaned my car to a Missionary friend who returned to this country for Christmas, who was aged 55 with a clean licence and full NCB when he owned a car...
 

Value my car

Save £75 on Warranty using code HJ75

with MotorEasy

Get a warranty quote

Save 12% on GAP Insurance

Use HJ21 to save on an ALA policy

See offer