What is life like with your car? Let us know and win £500 in John Lewis vouchers | No thanks

Are all-weather tyres adequate for use in snow, or should I fit dedicated winter tyres?

I have a set of Pirelli Scorpion STR tyres on a Volvo XC70. I discussed winter tyres with my local tyre dealer last year and he pointed out that Scorpions are designated M+S and, although not true winter tyres, are designed as all-weather tyres. My experience with these tyres during the last two winter in snow and ice was that they performed extremely well even in deep snow. I have no experience of winter tyres and would value your opinion about this issue. I always carry chains for the front wheels in case of exceptional weather conditions, particularly in the Alps.

Asked on 2 April 2012 by PC, Blackheath

Answered by Honest John
Land Rover specifies 225/55 R19 Pirelli Scorpion STRs and ATRs for Discovery 4s, Range Rover Sports and Range Rovers. They are also the best tyres for Mercedes-Benz GLs, Volvo XC70s and Audi Allroads. Pirelli does do Sotto Zero high performance winter tyres, but there are five types of Scorpion Tyres, one of which is specifically for ice and snow.
Similar questions
My daughter has a Volkswagen Polo S 1.2. We're in a rural location and I organise a winter tyre swap for my elder daughter. I wondered whether the Polo could run on all weather tyres instead. Is this feasible?...
My wife's 2015 Toyota RAV4 needs new tyres and ideally I'd like to buy some modern all-season tyres. Neither Michelin Cross Climates or Goodyear Vector 4 Seasons seem to be available in 235 / 55 / 18....
Aviva has told me that I don't need to tell them I have fitted cold weather tyres, but I understand that other insurers do require it. A colleague told me that winter tyres might be illegal in the summer...
Related models
Smart-looking 4WD estate with more off-road ability than the previous XC70. Comfortable, safe and practical.