What is life like with your car? Let us know and win £500 in John Lewis vouchers | No thanks

How can I respond after a third party dishonestly claimed for injury after I scratched his car?

In December 2010 I parked outside a shop very early in the snow and ice. When I came out the car park was empty. I reversed back, but could not see properly with ice on my rear window. I heard a noise, and discovered a taxi driver had parked behind me, while I was adjusting things and starting my car. I felt responsible, and had marked his rear door. He became very friendly, and would get it repaired, and get an estimate. He wanted over £500, which was ridiculous, and then got very angry when I decided to go through my insurance.

I have been driving for 40 years without claiming anything from my own insurance. I lost two years' NCD. I then received a nasty letter from a solicitor, claiming personal injuries caused by my negligent driving. I sent the insurance company a full report, telling them exactly what happened. The only injury was to my nerves, and the taxi man's greed. You can imagine how disgusted and betrayed I felt, when I discovered this greedy little man has been paid over £6000 for personal injury, loss of earnings and damage to his car. The insurance company doubled my premium this year.

Is it any wonder that insurance is rising so much? I receive texts wanting me to claim for injury, 'no win no fee'. This is 'legal theft'. Afraid of court fees, insurance companies are settling out of court. I now have a personal injury claim on record. They could have showed the magistrate my letter and description of the accident. Their insurance assessor would have had to examine the car for damage. I feel betrayed. I could not believe how easy it is to get money like this through complete dishonesty. Where will it end?

Asked on 5 May 2012 by DL, Belfast

Answered by Honest John
The government is aware of this, but many of these spurious claims are organised by outfits run from India where there is no control. You could set a legal precedent by suing the taxi driver for your losses arising out of his spurious claim. After all, how could he have been injured in a car that was stationary and was merely scratched. Sue the scumbag in the Small Claims Track of the County Court and see if he's prepared to risk a stretch inside for perjury. That would be interesting. Inform your insurer of your intention so that it can manage its own interest in the judge’s ruling.
Similar questions
I had an unsolicited call from someone who did not identify themselves, advising me that there was money available to me for personal injury resulting from an accident in 2009. They had all the details...
I have been following your correspondence concerning "Claims Management" and whiplash scams. Can you give advice what to do at the time of an incident, please? Is it possible to deter the other party...
I just received a text from a mobile number stating: "Free Msg; Our records indicate you may be entitled to £3,750 for the accident you had. To apply free reply CLAIM to this message. To opt out text STOP.”...
 

Value my car

Save £75 on Warranty using code HJ75

with MotorEasy

Get a warranty quote

Save 12% on GAP Insurance

Use HJ21 to save on an ALA policy

See offer