What is life like with your car? Let us know and win £500 in John Lewis vouchers | No thanks
Clutch and Big Ends Failed at same time. What's the cause?
Nissan X-Trail Arctix expedition sports adventure, 2008 173bhp 33,000 miles, 7 months out of warranty.
Clutch burned out, big ends gone, new engine required, cost over £10,000. Nissan don't want to know have said it is normal wear and tear. The car tows a caravan twice a year for approx 300 mile round trip, all other driving is normal commuting.
I am at a loss to understand why if the big ends are gone, do I need a new engine? I am not technically minded but why the clutch would go and then the big ends, as I am sure one problem cannot cause the other. The car is maintained to a very high standard, serviced yearly at Nissan dealership. There was plenty oil in engine, the technician confirmed this.
So far have been unable to get past Nissan customer care contact centre where a girl called Laura has confirmed that it is normal wear and tear and as such Nissan will not be making any contribution to the cost of repair. It's a £20,000 car that is now lying in a garage worth nothing.
Any advice would be greatly appreciated.
Clutch burned out, big ends gone, new engine required, cost over £10,000. Nissan don't want to know have said it is normal wear and tear. The car tows a caravan twice a year for approx 300 mile round trip, all other driving is normal commuting.
I am at a loss to understand why if the big ends are gone, do I need a new engine? I am not technically minded but why the clutch would go and then the big ends, as I am sure one problem cannot cause the other. The car is maintained to a very high standard, serviced yearly at Nissan dealership. There was plenty oil in engine, the technician confirmed this.
So far have been unable to get past Nissan customer care contact centre where a girl called Laura has confirmed that it is normal wear and tear and as such Nissan will not be making any contribution to the cost of repair. It's a £20,000 car that is now lying in a garage worth nothing.
Any advice would be greatly appreciated.
Asked on 7 October 2012 by Jb&Eb
Answered by
Honest John
I don't understand this either. Can understand the clutch getting burned out from extricating the caravan. Can't understand why the big ends failed. All I can think of is that you destroyed the oil by switching off the engine when the turbo was red hot from towing. You should have idled it for a couple of minutes. if the oil was carbonised then bits could have got into the oilways to the big ends and that's what caused them to fail.
Tags:
technical issues
Similar questions
I have a 2009 Nissan X-Trail with a six-speed automatic gearbox. The vehicle has covered 38,000 miles and tows a caravan in the summer. Last week the vehicle made a strange thud noise. Once was whilst...
I bought my 2011 Nissan X-Trail about nine months ago and it's still under warranty. However, over the past few weeks, I've noticed an engine whistle which is getting louder. Is this a problem and does...
The CD player on my 2004 Nissan X-Trail has stopped working. The radio is ok and I have managed to buy a used Nissan radio with a CD changer, but I am unsure how to fit it. Can you offer any advice?
Related models
Excellent drive on tarmac and very competent off road, large boot, plenty of standard equipment.