What is life like with your car? Let us know and win £500 in John Lewis vouchers | No thanks

Why are automatic number plate readers on speed cameras so inaccurate?

I was surprised to receive a Notice of Intended Prosecution (NIP) for allegedly travelling at 56mph along a stretch of dual carriageway I know has a 40mph speed limit - which I do consciously try to observe. If it had alleged 45mph I might well have accepted that I had carelessly exceeded the limit, but not by 16mph. I therefore requested the photographic evidence.

I'm pleased I did as the photo I received showed a motorcycle - not my silver Honda Jazz. Upon enquiry it seems that vehicle registration plates are not read by the human eye but by optical character recognition technology, resulting in a staggering four of the eight characters on the motorcycle's registration plate being mis-read. The letter admitting the error stated that "cases such as this are extremely rare". However the fact that this letter was clearly a standard one with a stereotyped signature suggests that this occurrence is not as rare as it claimed. So if you receive a NIP get the photographic evidence - or you may end up paying some one else's fine and having their points on your driving licence.

Asked on 16 June 2011 by BC, Bexhill-on-Sea

Answered by Honest John
Thank you very much for that email. I will do everything I can to ensure that it runs. I cannot abide lazy persecutions and prosecutions, which is what this amounts to.
Similar questions
I have recently been dunned for £60 for speeding by an unmanned camera, all, apparently, in the interests of road safety. This raises the question of who audits the money? I feel that it merely goes to...
Many years ago I believe you ran a item in your pages concerning a lorry driver being found guilty by police for warning drivers of a speed check/trap, but on appeal to the law lords he was exonerated....
I have recently received an NIP from a mobile speed camera. The camera 'warning' signs on the approach to the camera van were obscured by foliage. Do I have a defence to the ticket?