My problem is probably not uncommon. Some 5 years ago I suffered a series of strokes, which left me with an insubordinate left leg. I was advised by our local assessment centre to switch to automatic transmission. Probably in denial of the enforced change I insisted on semi-automatic, the rationale being lower consumption hence lower emissions, and lower VED.

So we obtained a Ford Fusion automated manual. Last week, as I passed a bus at a bus stop on a hill and as I changed down for more power the gearbox 'brain' failed. Very embarrassing. Fortunately our village garage came out and collected it and has passed it to the Ford dealer who has diagnosed solenoid failure and possible actuator failure at an estimated cost of nearly £2,000, more than the car is worth.

I am reluctant to let go as I have come to respect the Fusion for its driveability, very Fiesta-like, and load carrying capacity, for a wife who shops on an industrial scale. I would like to ask is it practical to get another semi-automatic or should I forget it and go for a manual? My son-in-law suggests a diesel auto, but on our low mileage I think not, I would appreciate your advice on a replacement vehicle.