What is life like with your car? Let us know and win £500 in John Lewis vouchers | No thanks

Red alert - fix or not to fix

I am the owner of a 2003 Rover 75 1.8T. Having had a full service and MOT a month ago, on a recent journey the temperature gauge shot up to red. I stopped the car and it was taken home by recovery.

My garage has informed me that the cylinder head needs replacing and the cost of the job will be i£1,000-£1,200 plus VAT. Is this about right? I was considering changing my car before this happened. Is it best to have the job done and then sell it? (economically viable?) The car has only done 43,000 miles and is in very good condition otherwise.

Or do you think it better to try and sell as it is?

Asked on 15 January 2010 by AS, Newport, Shrops

Answered by Honest John
The old Rover K Series 4-cylinder engine was designed with a very small coolant capacity to make it more efficient. However, the ‘O’ ring gaskets between the cylinder head and the water-heated inlet manifold eventually fail, the coolant leaks and, because the capacity of coolant is small, this rapidly leads to overheating and failure of the cylinder head gasket or worse. Knowing the engine had this fault, in your case, Rover’s brilliant engineers fitted it with a turbocharger that runs red hot a lot of the time.

In my experience a car that has suffered a failed head gasket is never right again, so my advice is to get rid of it. Even repaired it’s only worth about £1,500. The curious thing is that the Chinese have taken this same engine and designed a range of cars around it. Maybe the have solved the ‘O’ ring problem. Maybe no one in China dares to complain.
Similar questions
My new car (a BMW 320i xdrive) is due to arrive in two weeks. I am trying to sell my 2006 56-plate Audi A4 3.0TDI quattro auto with 62,500 miles. It has all the extras (except nav), and is covered by the...
My wife has decided to cease driving for health reasons and reluctantly must part with her 1986 Mini that has been with her for almost all of the past 24 years. The car is garaged, very low mileage, gold...
I'm the owner of a 2004 Rover 75 which I am reluctant to part with it. It's a great car and very comfortable. However, twice in the last four years the head gasket has failed, and I was recently presented...