What is life like with your car? Let us know and win £500 in John Lewis vouchers | No thanks

The price of diesels

I own a 2007 Citroen C4 Picasso with the 1.6HDi engine (about 110bhp I think) with the DPF. However it seems that it is essential for these engines to be run with C2 grade engine oil (low sulphur and ash content). Unfortunately, prior to me purchasing my car second hand with 13,000 miles on the clock, the car had been serviced by a Citroen dealer with Shell Helix F, which is not C2 grade. Two years and a service with the correct oil later (at 25,000 miles on the clock), the turbo has failed, which will cost a whopping £2,500 to repair at my local Citroen garage. A quick Google on this issue suggests this is very common on this engine, which is fitted to Citroen, Peugeots, Fords, Volvos and, until last year, MINI Cooper Ds. I contacted four well-known turbo specialists in the UK. All of them commented to the effect of "there is a problem with the 1.6HDi engine in these cars", and one refused to sell or repair the turbo for this engine altogether as it would "probably fail again soon after replacement". My local Citroen garage has request support from Citroen for the replacement, but here is the catch: Citroen has requested some extensive diagnostics work (£500), which I have to pay before they will consider the claim, which of course they have no obligation to support. I wonder if this is a deliberate effort to prevent either out-of-warranty replacement costs *or* the rejection of claims for the same appearing in their records? As it stands it seems I have little option but to get the car repaired at an independent garage, for about £1,500, and then move the vehicle on as soon as possible. It seems far from ideal.

Asked on 9 January 2010 by JP, via email

Answered by Honest John
I have not received any more news of turbo failure with this engine than with any other turbodiesel. However, turbos in diesels generally don't seem to last. Neither do dual mass flywheels, EGRs and diesel particulate filters. Which is why I am warning anyone buying a diesel with their own money to prepare themselves for potentially around £5,000 worth of repairs and replacements during years 4 - 6 of the car's life. Petrol may not take you as many miles on a gallon. But doesn't cost anything like as much in repairs and replacements. If you aren't going to be doing truly huge mileages, modern diesels cost far more than they save.
Similar questions
My husband is looking at buying a SEAT Altea TDI. I've read a few comments on the internet about the turbo blowing and costing a fortune to repair. Is this a common fault? We had a Ford C-Max TDCI a year...
My 2006 Skoda Octavia 1.9 TDI PD Estate has just completed 150,000 miles, 145,000 miles in my ownership plus 5000 as the dealer’s demonstration car. The only major expense I have incurred was for a dual...
We are considering replacing our 2007 Skoda 1.9TDI Estate as it has now done over 100,000 miles. We have been extremely happy with it, mostly using it for 150 miles at a time for motorway driving. We have...
Related models
Versatile five-seat cabin with a 500-litre boot, plenty of clever touches inside, easy to fold rear seats, comfortable ride, decent value for money.
 

Value my car

Save £75 on Warranty using code HJ75

with MotorEasy

Get a warranty quote

Save 12% on GAP Insurance

Use HJ21 to save on an ALA policy

See offer