What is life like with your car? Let us know and win £500 in John Lewis vouchers | No thanks
Damage caused in private car park
I was driving off a small private car park (which serves a Blockbuster Video store, to which I had just returned dvds) when a large, steel security gate at the end of the building, (which is supposed to secure the external fire escape stairs serving the upper storey of the building) swung open and hit my passenger side wing causing an estimated £500 worth of damage.
It transpired that the loose gate had been reported by the upstairs tenant's via email and, on a couple of occasions, to the landlords, but nothing had been done (the problem was that the latch on the gate was rusted in the open position).
I have photos and the upstairs tenants (a housing association company) also took photos and saw the damage sustained by my vehicle.
I have written to the Landlord and provided full details and photos, asking how they wish to proceed, but no response yet. I feel they must be liable, as the problem of the loose gate attached to their building had been reported but they did nothing about it until, of course, the day my car was hit and their tenants rang to inform them of the fact. At that point someone was dispatched to fix it within hours.
Am I correct in thinking that even though the car park has the usual "at owners risk" notice displayed, a fixture from the building itself swinging out and hitting me makes the Landlord liable to pay for the damage to my vehicle?
It transpired that the loose gate had been reported by the upstairs tenant's via email and, on a couple of occasions, to the landlords, but nothing had been done (the problem was that the latch on the gate was rusted in the open position).
I have photos and the upstairs tenants (a housing association company) also took photos and saw the damage sustained by my vehicle.
I have written to the Landlord and provided full details and photos, asking how they wish to proceed, but no response yet. I feel they must be liable, as the problem of the loose gate attached to their building had been reported but they did nothing about it until, of course, the day my car was hit and their tenants rang to inform them of the fact. At that point someone was dispatched to fix it within hours.
Am I correct in thinking that even though the car park has the usual "at owners risk" notice displayed, a fixture from the building itself swinging out and hitting me makes the Landlord liable to pay for the damage to my vehicle?
Asked on 24 June 2011 by IGT
Answered by
Honest John
I think you can prove negligence. If they won't settle out of court, take the case to the small claims track of the county court.
Similar questions
I rent a garage from a local housing association and I park my classic Saab 900 in there. I recently visited the garage to find that they had replaced the roof without informing and with the car in situ....
I have an Hyundai i10, mainly brought on your recommendations, which I purchased in Sept 09 (59 plate) and it has just had its first service. On driving out of the dealership, I started hearing a wind...
My Fiat Panda went into the Fiat dealer for some warranty work. When I returned to pick it up, someone had scratched from the front drivers door all the way to the back wing. They admitted fault and took...