What is life like with your car? Let us know and win £500 in John Lewis vouchers | No thanks
Low cost motorway driving
I need some advice on what car (probably second hand) to buy.
My priorities are:
MOST IMPORTANT:
1. Low *overall* cost motoring
2. Quiet & comfortable with good ride on motorways (long journeys & making phone calls from car)
3. Good-ish acceleration (for safe overtaking). (0-60 in c.8 or 9 secs max)
DESIRABLE:
4. Ideally need a hatchback (for transporting larger items)
5. Good cornering (fun & saves fuel).
6. Cruise control (useful for long journeys)
7. Easy to park
WHAT DOES NOT MATTER:
- I do not care about make of car/image.
- I do not care what the car looks like.
BACKGROUND CONSTRAINTS:
- I am open to leasing, purchasing new or buying second hand.
- I have about GBP 10,000+ to throw at the problem.
- I do about 20,000 miles per year.
- I am in my early 50s.
- I have 3 years no claims bonus.
MY INITIAL THOUGHTS:
I have been advised to buy an old second hand Honda Accord, c. 1996 which apparently "never break down".
AVERAGE HISTORY COSTS:
I have just run the numbers for over the last 4 years, which are:
Depreciation: GBP 1,400 per year
Diesel: GBP 1,800 per year
Repairs/parts: GPP 2,100 per year
Current car: Golf TDI 1.9 (150 BHP I think).
Mileage: 16,000 miles per year (about to be 20,000)
DISCUSSION:
To me the huge surprise is just how small a proportion of overall costs is fuel - even now it's only about 33% !
Any advice?
My priorities are:
MOST IMPORTANT:
1. Low *overall* cost motoring
2. Quiet & comfortable with good ride on motorways (long journeys & making phone calls from car)
3. Good-ish acceleration (for safe overtaking). (0-60 in c.8 or 9 secs max)
DESIRABLE:
4. Ideally need a hatchback (for transporting larger items)
5. Good cornering (fun & saves fuel).
6. Cruise control (useful for long journeys)
7. Easy to park
WHAT DOES NOT MATTER:
- I do not care about make of car/image.
- I do not care what the car looks like.
BACKGROUND CONSTRAINTS:
- I am open to leasing, purchasing new or buying second hand.
- I have about GBP 10,000+ to throw at the problem.
- I do about 20,000 miles per year.
- I am in my early 50s.
- I have 3 years no claims bonus.
MY INITIAL THOUGHTS:
I have been advised to buy an old second hand Honda Accord, c. 1996 which apparently "never break down".
AVERAGE HISTORY COSTS:
I have just run the numbers for over the last 4 years, which are:
Depreciation: GBP 1,400 per year
Diesel: GBP 1,800 per year
Repairs/parts: GPP 2,100 per year
Current car: Golf TDI 1.9 (150 BHP I think).
Mileage: 16,000 miles per year (about to be 20,000)
DISCUSSION:
To me the huge surprise is just how small a proportion of overall costs is fuel - even now it's only about 33% !
Any advice?
Asked on 9 May 2011 by ship69
Answered by
Honest John
This is a "you've done your own sums" number.
You're right. No point in saving relatively small amounts on diesel if the diesel is going to bring huge bills for DMFs, DPFs, etc.
I'd look at a Mondeo III 1.8 or 2.0 petrol with the swirl flaps taken out of the inlet manifold.
They go for buttons, last well, and are cheap to fix. Much cheaper than a Honda.
You're right. No point in saving relatively small amounts on diesel if the diesel is going to bring huge bills for DMFs, DPFs, etc.
I'd look at a Mondeo III 1.8 or 2.0 petrol with the swirl flaps taken out of the inlet manifold.
They go for buttons, last well, and are cheap to fix. Much cheaper than a Honda.
Our honest used car pricing is a little bit different to all the others. You can get to our values through make or model - you don’t have to follow a prescribed route. Plus, it’s live, which means we can react to changes in the market quicker than any printed price guide.
Honest Used Car Prices
From which small car to buy at which price point to the best UK-built cars, our Top 10s have the lot. Click now for your shortlist.
Unsure of what to buy? Our Top 10s are here to help you....
Dear Honest John,
Please help me choose my next car. I would like it to have:
Please help me choose my next car. I would like it to have:
Similar questions
Three years ago I purchased a Nissan Note Accenta 1.6 Automatic with 16" wheels and although only having done 12,000 miles have been very pleased with the car which you were recommending regularly. Only...
I have a real heartache over my newly purchased 07 plate Berlingo van and really hope you could point me in the right direction!
On 6th of June this year I bought this van from a dealer near Sheffield....
I bought a Rover 75 from a dealer 3 weeks ago and a garage check told me that the track rod ends were worn and need replacing.
The dealer told me that I was given a 28 day warranty. Is this fair wear...
.jpg)
