What is life like with your car? Let us know and win £500 in John Lewis vouchers | No thanks

Which safe, reliable cars do you recommend?

What’s the safest, most reliable car that will work with two adults, three tall kids and a large dog? Given where prices are at the moment I’d like an option for something newish up to £50,000, we’d keep for 8 years, and something more like £20,000, which we’d keep for a couple of years until used prices become more sensible and the supply chain issues for new ones becomes better.

Asked on 10 January 2022 by Carl Bourne

Answered by Russell Campbell
I would recommend a Volvo XC90 on your £50,000 budget. It's one of the safest cars on sale, has plenty of room for three tall kids in the back and a boot that will have your dog thinking it's died and gone to puppy heaven. You can have it as a petrol, diesel or plug-in hybrid. Your budget is enough to get you a 2020 model with around 10,000 miles on the clock.

On a £20,000 budget, I would go for a Toyota RAV4 hybrid. You'll get a 2018 car with 70,000 miles on the clock – Toyota's legendary reliability means you shouldn't be put off by the mileage and it's interior should have worn the miles well. It's not quite as roomy as the Volvo, but it's not far off. Like the Volvo, it has a five-star rating for safety from NCAP, although the Toyota was tested under 2013's less rigorous conditions. Plus, the hybrid is excellent on fuel and should make the car an attractive purchase when you sell it on in a couple of years.
Similar questions
I'm looking to buy a new or used 4x4. My budget is around £350 per month. My weekly drive isn't much, just a 20-mile round commute, but I plan go camping at weekends. I don't need a big Land Rover Discovery-sized...
I drive a Mercedes-Benz Sprinter van for work and find the seating position very comfortable as I have a bad knee which aches a lot in a normal car seat. What car (new or used) would have the closest seating...
I have moved to Devon where the roads are hilly and windy. I would appreciate your suggestion for a 4x4 which has a high driving position (as opposed to 4x4 cars), good spacious feel in the cabin (don't...
Related models
Incredibly refined and quiet on the move, high quality cabin with room for seven, well equipped as standard.
Hybrid fuel economy. Comfortable interior. Good build quality.