What is life like with your car? Let us know and win £500 in John Lewis vouchers | No thanks

A Polo count-down

I am a 48-year-old single mother of 4 and have just qualified as a nurse. I have got a job as a community staff nurse, which involves a lot of travelling. My present car is a 2000X Polo (bought 2nd hand from a dealer in Kent for about £5,000 two years ago on HP) and I can only drive automatic cars, which limits my choice (I only have an automatic licence). Any car trader can see me coming miles away with a large ‘rip-me-off ‘sign as I do not know anything about cars and have got ripped off many times in the past. I am asking if you could recommend whether I should trade my present car in and get something else as my Polo although it is very good. It is heavy on petrol and I spend on average £20 - £30 a week on fuel. Brand new cars do not excite me as I am not worried about the aesthetics of the vehicle or how good it looks, just the reliability and the economy of it. I am still paying off my Polo and will not have loads to spend so I am not necessarily looking for a brand new car. I could put £1,000 down if I sell a family heirloom, or should I trade in my car? My children can work towards buying their own old banger between them so I do not have to accommodate for them necessarily. Can you recommend anything to me?

Asked on 19 December 2009 by

Answered by Honest John
If the Polo is running okay I don't think you will be able to reduce your
fuel bills significantly with a newer automatic in the price range you are talking about, except, perhaps with a Toyota Yaris 1.3 4-speed automatic. That should do well over 40mpg on runs. But because they are highly regarded, they tend to be quite dear used and that is a recipe for another rip-off. You might save £5 - £10 a week on fuel, but that's only £260 - £320 a year, which is peanuts compared to the cost of financing a newer car.
Similar questions
Why do summer and winter mpg figures vary?
I have a Jaguar XE, nearly two years old, which averages around 39mpg on the computer set for long periods. 2000 miles ago I decided to check real mpg by checking fill-ups against mileage and was surprised...
I have an Hyundai Ioniq, which I've run exclusively on Shell fuels for the 5000 miles that I've had it. I was getting 60-62 mpg on the regular stuff, then put a tank of the V-Power in and got 64 mpg. I...
Related models
Facelifted Polo III, still with an upmarket image. Better than pre-facelift and all now have power steering.
 

Value my car

Save £75 on Warranty using code HJ75

with MotorEasy

Get a warranty quote

Save 12% on GAP Insurance

Use HJ21 to save on an ALA policy

See offer