What is life like with your car? Let us know and win £500 in John Lewis vouchers | No thanks

Intelligence pest

I have been reading with interest and shock that Transport for London is looking at the idea of Speed curbing - also known as intelligent speed adaptation (ISA). Bar the obvious reduction in speed camera fines I can only see pitfalls. I use a SatNav and when I accelerate on a motorway slip road I often get a warning that I am over the speed limit as it thinks I am in a 30 mph zone. This could prove lethal if I was limited with the Speed Curbing device as I would not be able to integrate easily in to the motorway traffic. Often accelerating beyond the speed limit, for a very short period, to pass a lorry on a motorway or 'get out of trouble' like when trying to get out of the blind spot of a vehicle merging from the left can be life saving. What would happen in temporary speed limits for road works? Would all cars automatically break the same when going from a 50 to a 30 mph limit? I can see lots or rear end shunts when one model breaks harder than another as the driver has had their sensation of speed taken away from them because the computer is controlling the cars speed. I also fear that would drivers to 'shut off' mentally and let the car do the thinking. What people need to do is be more aware on the roads. I don't constantly look down at my speedometer to check my speed, I have an awareness of my speed and I am usually correct give or take 2 - 4 mph. A reader the other week commented that they'd now only drive at 50 mph on the motorways to avoid a speeding fine, if they can't tell which side of the speed limit they are by 20 mph they should not be allowed on the road. If drivers were to concentrate more on the roads rather than being on mobile phones, changing CD's, smoking or whatever else it is that distracts them we'd have safer roads.

Asked on 28 November 2009 by

Answered by Honest John
You are 100% right. Can I add your mail to Idris Francis e-mail campaign? What will have happened here is, as with privatising motorways, an investment bank or associated private equity firm will have take over a credible pressure group (RAC Foundation) and used it to advocate and lobby for something it can make a fortune out of. With ISA it won't have needed to. There are already a handful of 'road safety' pressure groups that are used by anyone wanting to make money out of vilifying, controlling and punishing motorists. We should all concern ourselves with 'who's going to make the billions?' out of ISA rather than fight the issue itself. (30,000,000 ISA units at £100 profit a unit makes someone £3,000,000,000.)
Similar questions
I was interested in a recent letter about Intelligent Speed Adaptation for cars. I live in the New Forest and our local paper is full of ideas to prevent animal accidents, speeding, etc. One wished to...
Technically, with ‘Intelligent Speed Adaptation’ by GPS, speeding can be prevented. There is no need to cover the country with expensive "speed sensitive stop lights". The object is not to punish anybody,...
Intelligent Speed Adaptation. Let me tell you my experience a with cruise control which was switched off. Went into a parking place when the engine suddenly raced at full throttle and I was nearly sent...
 

Value my car

Save £75 on Warranty using code HJ75

with MotorEasy

Get a warranty quote

Save 12% on GAP Insurance

Use HJ21 to save on an ALA policy

See offer