What is life like with your car? Let us know and win £500 in John Lewis vouchers | No thanks
Roll reversal
With regards to your reply to W.B. on August 15th, I have been driving for 50 years and am now in my mid-seventies. I have never fancied an automatic, partly because you warn older people off them. However, 3 years ago my son persuaded me to try one - a Kia Picanto, almost new, and I was hooked. I have never driven it 2-footed; I put my left foot on the convenient rest and leave it there, and drive happily all over the place. I have never for one moment got in a mess with it. So, I love your column, but on this I don't agree with you.
Asked on 7 November 2009 by
Answered by
Honest John
A Picanto is so small that there is less chance of killing someone with
one, but around 120 people a year are killed due to loss of control of automatics, mostly while manoeuvring. The police call it "unintentional acceleration syndrome". Pretty simply, really. You can never be 100% sure of controlling an automatic with the accelerator alone. A recent case was of an elderly gentleman who reversed into his wife of 50 years and was than unable to stop his car before he ran her over and killed her. He had always driven an automatic one footed, and, like you, trusted the car too much. Had he been driving two footed then he could have stopped instantly and this tragedy would never have occurred. Obviously you have to make your own decision about left foot braking out on the roads. Drivers with decent co-ordination can drive more smoothly that way. Those with two right feet can't. FAQ on the subject at www.honestjohn.co.uk I drive around 50 different automatics a year and around 50 different
manuals and own both manual and automatic cars.
one, but around 120 people a year are killed due to loss of control of automatics, mostly while manoeuvring. The police call it "unintentional acceleration syndrome". Pretty simply, really. You can never be 100% sure of controlling an automatic with the accelerator alone. A recent case was of an elderly gentleman who reversed into his wife of 50 years and was than unable to stop his car before he ran her over and killed her. He had always driven an automatic one footed, and, like you, trusted the car too much. Had he been driving two footed then he could have stopped instantly and this tragedy would never have occurred. Obviously you have to make your own decision about left foot braking out on the roads. Drivers with decent co-ordination can drive more smoothly that way. Those with two right feet can't. FAQ on the subject at www.honestjohn.co.uk I drive around 50 different automatics a year and around 50 different
manuals and own both manual and automatic cars.
Similar questions
I have successfully completed the Institute of Advanced Motorists (IAM) driving course, which, considering that it is almost 40 yrs since I passed my driving test, was a great opportunity to refresh my...
I would like to endorse you advice in using automatics. In the 1960s I took over my father's automatic Jag, having just sold a manual Mk2. I quickly worked out that two feet was the way to drive it. Later...
I quote from the IAM handbook - "Advanced Driving - the essential guide" in which and I quote, from page 46: "As a rule, left foot braking is best avoided, it is a tricky technique that's best left to...
Related models
Great value small car that is cheap to buy and run. Seven-year warranty on all new models from January 2010. Good rear passenger room. Much improved interior on facelifted cars from 2007.