What is life like with your car? Let us know and win £500 in John Lewis vouchers | No thanks

Questionable behaviour

Please could you give me some advice on what car to buy? Ideally, I'd like a new or pre-registered either BMW 520d, or an Audi A4/A6 diesel. I've got £24k + trade in to play with. Or, reading that you've got a Focus series 3 1.6 Diesel on loan, how is this going? Would you give it your 100% recommendation? I'd like to buy new, or pre registered (as long as it has not been standing around getting rusty brakes and flat spotted tyres). This would save a lot of money. Currently, I drive an 55 plate (October 2005) Ford Mondeo Zetec 130TDCI 5dr Hatch, in Silver. 50,500 miles on the clock. Just had a 50k service on it. Reading that 3 year old cars are in short supply, are 2nd hand values really that good? Would you say that now is the best time to buy?

Asked on 11 July 2009 by

Answered by Honest John
A lot of separate questions. ‘My’ Focus ECOnetic went on Thursday 28th May after having averaged 54.98mpg over 7,178 miles. No problems at all. Did not even use any oil (my previous C-Max 2.0TDCI used about a litre over a similar distance). Strangely, the 1.6TDCI actually develops more torque at lower revs than the 2.0TDCI, which is why it is now finding its way into big Volvos like the V70 and S80. It's a very pleasant, accommodating engine to drive. Better and less dieselly than the 2.0TDCI. The A6 is coming to the end of its production life and will be replaced with a model using the same drivetrain as the A4 B8. My favourite A4 B8 is the 2.7V6 TDCI Multitronic, though if you were scared by the word Multitronic I don't blame you. I'll soon be testing a SEAT Exeo, which is basically the old model A4 B7 with the current B8 2.0 litre common rail piezo injected engine. The 143PS version of that impressed me enormously and still managed 50mpg. So that could be on the list. The new Skoda Superb is also very impressive, if a bit ugly, with limo-like rear legroom, but no rear wiper because of its hatchback and bootlid arrangement. A BMW 520d feels its weight a bit, but is okay. There had been a worry of this engine going through turbos a bit too rapidly.

But for £24k my choice would be a base model Mercedes W204 C200CDI Classic SE manual. That car felt to me like it would do 1,000,000 miles, and I actually liked it more than the C320CDI estate I tried on a later date.

At the time of writing (late May) used values were still high and with Sterling still at a comparatively poor rate I would say that prices of imported new cars will have to go up again.
Dear Honest John,

Please help me choose my next car. I would like it to have:
    Select a few terms below
Similar questions
I have a Seat Altea 2.0TDI Sport with 168k on it. Should I swap it for a 1.6 iDTEC Honda Civic or a Mazda CX-5 diesel? With the new engines do you really get the quoted figures of near 60mpg?
What small car will not disappoint me when it replaces my seven year old Fiat 500 Lounge Automatic? Economic petrol consumption a must.
I need a new car and I like the Honda Civic and Alfa Romeo Giulietta. I will be doing mainly suburban driving, occasional motorway runs and low mileage - probably 6000/9000 miles a year. Essentials are:-...