What is life like with your car? Let us know and win £500 in John Lewis vouchers | No thanks

Tensioner, nervous headache

I have a Vectra 1.9TDCi registered in June 2006 with 71,205 on the clock. Last Monday, whilst driving home, the temperature shot up and the engine started making rattling noises without warning. The car was recovered to the local Vauxhall garage where they identified that one of the cam belt rollers had failed causing the cam belt to snap. During this failure, the water pump got damaged as did the head and valve system. The dealer approached Vauxhall who declined to pay for the repairs on the grounds that the car is out of its 3 year 60,000 mile warranty. The dealer advises me that there is a service advisory for replacing the cambelt and tensioners at 90,000 and the auxiliary rollers if noisy. My argument is that Vauxhall should pay for the repairs, irrespective of the fact that the mileage is greater than the specified warranty mileage, because:
- the car is within the timescale of the warranty
- the car has a full Vauxhall service history
- I've never been instructed by a dealer that the affected parts should be replaced
As the auxiliary roller has failed there can be only two causes: it is not a robust design. Do you know if this is a frequently occurring failure in this engine? How can I find out who the supplier is / if they are located in a low cost (low quality) country / what their quality accreditation status. In either case, I believe that nothing I have done would have changed the circumstances of failure. Do you think this is a valid argument? Do you have any suggestions as to how else I can address this with Vauxhall as there is no way I can afford the repair bill of £1,781.64 as quoted by the dealer. I'd very much appreciate your comments.

Asked on 20 June 2009 by

Answered by Honest John
It's an Alfa Romeo diesel engine and Alfa engines are quite well known for these stupid plastic/nylon pulley failures. Ironically GM Opel/Vauxhall was famous for them in the 1990s. And VW for them in the mid 2000s. You'd think they'd have learned. They didn't. Just sourced their engines as cheaply as possible.
Similar questions
I refer to you an item in Sundays lifestyle regarding VAG`s 2.0 litre Diesel engines. For the benefit of someone who is non technical could you explain the benefits of the PD engine against the similarly...
I have a 2003/53 BMW530d SE E60 auto that has 101k on the clock and full service history (BMW up to 60k then synthetic oil every 10k after that.). The engine has just been written off because an intake...
Does Citroen/Peugeot use a Ford engine? I heard that from a local garage, is it true?
Related models
Far better than previous Vectra. Now with decent handling and an excellent ride. Plenty of safety kit. Roomy in the front. Big boot. Good looks.
 

Value my car

Save £75 on Warranty using code HJ75

with MotorEasy

Get a warranty quote

Save 12% on GAP Insurance

Use HJ21 to save on an ALA policy

See offer