What is life like with your car? Let us know and win £500 in John Lewis vouchers | No thanks

Indirect answer

You are my last resort after ringing round insurance companies. I bought a MINI One in April 2008, after checking with our insurance company, Direct Line, that the premium would be OK including my daughter aged 19 who had been driving for 6 months at the time. I gave them all the details about the car, including optional extras of sports suspension (lowered by 8mm), rear tinted windows and a rear spoiler (small lip off the back of the rear roof) and the premium was fine. I, and my daughter, are extremely pleased with the car. She went off to university in September so I took her off the insurance after checking that I could add her back in at Easter when she returned. When I phoned Direct Line this Easter they said I couldn’t insure her and that they should never have included her in the first place due to the optional extras - a company policy not to insure Under 25s with any extras on cars. To give them their due Direct Line did say they would refund if I decide to cancel, without any penalty charges, as it is their fault as I did notify them of the extras from the beginning. I have phoned a number of companies including Churchill and the AA but they also wont insure her. Do you know of any company which might be able to help otherwise I might have to replace the MINI with a standard one or buy an additional car, especially as my son is going to start learning in August when he is 17. Any help you can give us will be appreciated

Asked on 30 May 2009 by

Answered by Honest John
Direct line has replied to this as follows: “Direct Line does not refuse car insurance solely on age or car modifications. A range of factors affect the amount you pay for your car insurance policy including; age, type of vehicle, mileage, type of use, modifications to the vehicle, gender, occupation, postcode, claims history and any driving convictions or penalty points. It is a combination of these factors that determines the insurance premium or whether or not we will underwrite the business. Generally, any modifications to a car that increase the performance, value or its desirability to a thief will attract increased premiums as they may raise the risk, value or likelihood of a claim. Insurers will not generally penalise a customer for modifications that make a car safer or lower the risk of damage or theft. Direct Line customers are asked to disclose all alterations to their car's standard specification, including optional extras. Whether or not these were undertaken by the manufacturer, it is essential we are made aware of any modifications as it enables us to provide a fair and true quote. Non-disclosure of this information may have an impact on any future claim. Young drivers are the most likely group to make a claim on their insurance. Research amongst Direct Line's three million customers has shown young males have the highest claim rate amongst all ages and sexes during the first three years of driving, jumping from just over a one in five claim rate as a provisional driver, to two in five in the first full year. Young females start from a lower position of just under one in five, increasing to just less than one in three in the first year, before dropping steadily for the next three years.”
Similar questions
To begin with our son had his own insurance on his own car that covered him to drive other cars not belonging to him as long as they were insured by their owners. However, as time went by, he received...
My insurance company have cancelled my van insurance due to a mistake that was made when purchasing online. I forgot to declare a motoring conviction for a bald tire I received four years ago, will this...
I am a staff continuity announcer at a TV channel, with a 17 year old son who has just passed his driving test. I am currently insured by the RAC for an annual premium of £260. The quote to include my...
 

Value my car

Save £75 on Warranty using code HJ75

with MotorEasy

Get a warranty quote

Save 12% on GAP Insurance

Use HJ21 to save on an ALA policy

See offer