What is life like with your car? Let us know and win £500 in John Lewis vouchers | No thanks
Charge of the electric light brigade
So Gordon Brown wants us all to whizz around in electric cars because they are 'green'. I see plenty of downsides but not many upsides, except reduced pollution in cities. Which from cars is miniscule compared with chuffy buses and diesel taxis. Will we see electric trolley-buses again? Am I alone in thinking it is not very green to lug about heavy batteries which will have required massive amounts of energy to produce (on the other side of the World) and whose energy efficiency (mostly from a non-renewable source of generated power) is pretty poor when power-line losses are considered. Range is also limited and the time taken for recharge limits the vehicle's availability and usefulness. 60 miles, then an overnight charge, what nonsense is that? Hybrids are not much better. The high-tech batteries required use precious and scarce natural resources, are expensive and have limited life. And if they are similar to those used in laptops we can expect them to fire-up at regular intervals with more catastrophic results. It will be a while before an electric car replaces my 40-year old Land Rover, which weighs no more than a BMW MINI and has preserved World resources by me not having to replace it with 6-8 new cars during its life. Now that is green. The trouble with politicians is they do not look at all the factors in the equation. They select those that make the most palatable sound-bite.
Asked on 9 May 2009 by
Answered by
Honest John
Politicians always have a different agenda from the spin they use to increase taxes on anything that moves. To me the real issue is very simple. Internal Combustion engines are at their most efficient (far more efficient in converting energy to motion than electric motors) when they do a lot of miles. They are at their least efficient and least
environmentally friendly on short runs, and especially short runs from
cold that cause all sorts of problems. Worst are diesel engined cars with advanced emissions control systems such as particulate filters.
Many people on the Disablilty Mobility allowance get themselves an
Internal Combustion engined car and use it for very short runs of up to 1,000 - 2,000 miles a year. Since recipients of Disability Allowance are on government money anyway, surely the way forward is for the government to use this to encourage use of electric cars among those of them who don't drive big distances. Electric cars are not practical for long distance use and never will be. They make the most sense for short runs, or use within confined areas, such as cities.
Prime Minister Brown and his Government should be concentrating on that instead of using the idea of electric cars as environmental 'spin' to inflict yet more draconian taxes on owners of cars with Internal Combustion engines.
environmentally friendly on short runs, and especially short runs from
cold that cause all sorts of problems. Worst are diesel engined cars with advanced emissions control systems such as particulate filters.
Many people on the Disablilty Mobility allowance get themselves an
Internal Combustion engined car and use it for very short runs of up to 1,000 - 2,000 miles a year. Since recipients of Disability Allowance are on government money anyway, surely the way forward is for the government to use this to encourage use of electric cars among those of them who don't drive big distances. Electric cars are not practical for long distance use and never will be. They make the most sense for short runs, or use within confined areas, such as cities.
Prime Minister Brown and his Government should be concentrating on that instead of using the idea of electric cars as environmental 'spin' to inflict yet more draconian taxes on owners of cars with Internal Combustion engines.
Our honest used car pricing is a little bit different to all the others. You can get to our values through make or model - you don’t have to follow a prescribed route. Plus, it’s live, which means we can react to changes in the market quicker than any printed price guide.
Honest Used Car Prices
From which small car to buy at which price point to the best UK-built cars, our Top 10s have the lot. Click now for your shortlist.
Unsure of what to buy? Our Top 10s are here to help you....
Dear Honest John,
Please help me choose my next car. I would like it to have:
Please help me choose my next car. I would like it to have:
Similar questions
My job involves lots of small stop/start journeys (40-50 per day), sometimes only driving a few hundred yards, sometimes a couple of miles and I am using too much petrol in my Nissan Note automatic 1.6....
I was pleasantly surprised at reading about Renault's intention of developing 'quick drop stations' to swap batteries in their electric cars. For the past two or more years I have been banging on about...
You have occasionally commented on electric cars, but I guess you are unlikely to be fully aware of the future influence of such vehicles, specifically their impact within the context of global warming...
Elsewhere on 
.jpg)
