What is life like with your car? Let us know and win £500 in John Lewis vouchers | No thanks

Underbonnet spies

Speed limit signs should be safety advisory indicators. It is sensible to have speed limits to protect road workers and/or children, but not sensible to enforce them when no road workers are present or schools are closed. Most drivers drive to suit the conditions: people; time of day; road surface; weather; and traffic. Sometimes it is not safe to drive at the permitted speed. A 'decelerometer' device should be developed based on airbag trigger technology. When activated by a collision it would freeze at the vehicle's speed as registered by the car computer. Examination would indicate the speed. If that speed is over the speed limit it would be taken into account in the prosecution. The other hundred of thousands of cars that pass without incident will have done just that: "PASSED WITHOUT INCIDENT". Every M.O.T. test could require that a BLUE BOX (a car version of an aviation BLACK BOX) be fitted before a certificate is issued, and new cars would have one factory fitted. Civil servants could figure out the best way to ensure foreign vehicles enter the U.K. with a BLUE BOX fitted after a set date. At Police officer discretion (let's bring discretion back) 'hazardous' driving detected either by Police or observation cameras could still be regarded as a crime and put forward for prosecution whether or not it was within the permitted indicated speed limit. Bring back punishment for those who cause damage or injury, and free up the Police and the Courts for their proper mission.

Asked on 24 January 2009 by

Answered by Honest John
You make a fair point. Drivers should only get done if they have a crash or run someone over while exceeding the speed limit. But cars already do have black boxes. ECUs of high performance cars have the technology to record times, dates, engine speeds and vehicle speeds. That's how a woman driving a Jag was recently proved to have been speeding. Not every car has this, but even my FIAT 500 has the capability to record the car's fuel consumption, downloadable to a USB stick. If it can do that it can record other factors.
Similar questions
My son bought a new Volkswagen Golf GTE in September for his commute to work. He changed his insurance to an RAC policy with compulsory Black Box. The car had played up a bit in the last few weeks and...
Regarding insurance and a recent letter, if one attends a speed awareness course is it technically a speeding conviction and therefore to be declared to the insurer?
I have just received an NIP which states that on 12/12 I was caught speeding at 35mph in a 30mph zone - surprisingly enough, just before it jumps up to 40mph on a rural country road. My question, however,...
 

Value my car

Save £75 on Warranty using code HJ75

with MotorEasy

Get a warranty quote

Save 12% on GAP Insurance

Use HJ21 to save on an ALA policy

See offer