What is life like with your car? Let us know and win £500 in John Lewis vouchers | No thanks

Uplifting thought

As a fairly well seasoned motor trader of some seventeen years now I read your Saturday column with eager interest. Two points really, in the main it never ceases to amaze me that the vast majority of your readers are narrow in their thoughts. Frequently, those members of our society one would have thought would have been blessed with a reasonable dose of common sense are incapable of thinking “outside the box”. Many a time I read a tale of woe referring to some mishap or disaster or other with respect to their cars and the only apparent source of repair is the Main Stealer (sorry Main dealer). No thought is given to the idea of sourcing a used replacement item from the salvage system or indeed a reconditioned unit. My second point refers to a recent letter from a person unknown stating he had moved his fuel injected car ten feet or so and turned the thing off. The answer given to the problem was in my opinion wrong. The cause is not the over supply of fuel and the subsequent shutting down of the fuel but it is caused by the hydraulic lifters being jacked open due to the engine oil being thick and cold, thus no compression in the engine. Once the engine has been cranked for about 45 seconds with the throttle pedal depressed it should start. The answer is to change the engine oil. A thin oil is preferred i.e. 5/30 or even 0/30. So there you are, the true reason for the subsequent non-start.

Asked on 17 January 2009 by

Answered by Honest John
Unless the readers are constantly educated never to start cold engines then shut them off they will continue to have problems. The ECU refuses to start the engine in order to prevent neat fuel reaching the cat converter. A side benefit of that is the engine will not start with washed out bores and grind itself into destruction. Your diagnosis of the hydraulic lifters not pumping up is more likely to be true of older pre-cat engines. Unfortunately, the man who buys a £40k Jag and starts it just to run it onto his drive and clean it is often the same man who resents spending £50 on an essential oil change.
Tags: buying dealers
Dear Honest John,

Please help me choose my next car. I would like it to have:
    Select a few terms below
Similar questions
I ordered a new VW Golf PHEV in March 2022 with VW saying it would take 8 to 12 months. 16 months later we still have no build date for the car, do they want us to cancel the order because the cars have...
I've found a car I like but don't like the last bit of the number plate (KLL) - it looks like kill. Can the dealer change the number plate for me? It's a 68 plate car, so another 68-plate will be fine....
We're told we can negotiate a better deal on a new car towards the 'end of the month' when a salesman is keen, if not even desperate, to hit his/her target. But to do so successfully we must know when...