What is life like with your car? Let us know and win £500 in John Lewis vouchers | No thanks

Holed in one

I want to tell you about my mother-in-law's Peugeot 206, which she bought in March 2004 and in which she has driven just 13,800 miles. In September this year, she drove from Liverpool up to the Lake District. Half way, on the M6, she heard loud noises coming from the engine and pulled over to the hard shoulder. She called the AA, and because she's 77 years old they made her a priority. They picked her up and took her and the car and the dog to a garage in Windermere, close to where she had a hotel room booked for a few days. The mechanics discovered two large holes in the engine of the car and she was told that the only solution was to buy a new engine. This cost her just over £2,600. On her return, she contacted Peugeot. They told her that the car was outside its 3-year warranty and there was nothing they could do. They emphasised that because she had got it fixed in a non-Peugeot garage, that even if they'd wanted to compensate her they couldn't. She feels that the car had done relatively little mileage and therefore it seems likely that the engine was faulty and had she known that Peugeot only assist customers who take their cars to Peugeot outlets - even when they are away from home on a long journey to a holiday and have been taken to a reputable mechanic by the AA - she would have asked the AA to take her to one. So she wrote a second letter emphasising more clearly the points she'd made in the first. Once again, they said there was nothing they could do and that it wasn't their fault AA took her to a non-Peugeot outlet to fix the car. Does she have any rights at all?

Asked on 17 January 2009 by

Answered by Honest John
Sorry, Peugeot cannot take responsibility for this. Had the car been taken to a Peugeot dealer, the dealer would have contacted Peugeot and the real reason for the failure would have been established. As it is, the reason could have been that she failed to top up the oil. No one knows. Certainly not Peugeot
Similar questions
I always understood that if it was necessary to stop on the hard shoulder that it was advisable to point the steering towards the kerb. This would help to prevent that car being pushed into the moving...
I own a Mercedes C220CDI and at the last service I was advised that 3 glowplugs need replacing. A price was quoted but I was advised that if the plugs were difficult to remove or broke in the process the...
I contacted you a while back about great customer service I received at Toyota when replacing my engine and cat after developing a fault after 5 years and 90,000 miles. Well, here's one from the other...
Related models
Tidy looks and more practical than the hatch. Diesels are economical.