What is life like with your car? Let us know and win £500 in John Lewis vouchers | No thanks

Defeeted

A recent discussion with some friends concerning left foot braking in an automatic prompted me to write this e-mail. I have driven automatics for around 25 years and when I hire a car, I always hire an automatic. I brake with my right foot. Without exception, with every automatic I have driven, my left foot (on the foot rest) is further away from the brake pedal than my right foot (on the accelerator). Also what is the difference between braking with the right foot in an automatic and in a car with manual transmission?

Asked on 3 July 2010 by MP, Gailingen, Germany

Answered by Honest John
One day while manoeuvring, when the engine revs just a little bit more than you expect and you can't get your right foot up off the accelerator and down onto the brake, or if you miss the brake and catch the accelerator with your right foot instead, you will at least damage the car and at worst kill someone. Sadly, when this happens, the driver usually kills someone very dear to him or her. Just bear that in mind. (Co-ordinated drivers brake with either their right foot or their left foot whether driving manuals or automatics, depending on what they want the car to do, but that requires more skill than simply left foot braking an automatic in a manoeuvring situation.) Full explanation at: www.honestjohn.co.uk/faq/driving-automatics-safely
Similar questions
Your response to PB's letter on 19 June states that "in an automatic, left-foot braking is the only way to remain in full control of the vehicle at all times". As we manual drivers brake with our right...
I actually know an automatic right foot only driver. Although she didn't kill or injure anyone, she managed to create mayhem and damage six other cars in the Co-op Supermarket car park in Penistone, W....
With regard to using your left foot to brake an automatic, this will probably only work if someone uses the method from their introduction to driving and never drives anything but an auto. Otherwise, it'll...