What is life like with your car? Let us know and win £500 in John Lewis vouchers | No thanks

Undue courtesy?

My experiences regarding courtesy cars have always been where the car was provided by the accident repair company. My 87-year-old sister has recently had an incident where a van has shunted her parked car and damaged front and rear. Everyone, including the police, has been helpful but the insurance company has arranged for a courtesy car company to contact her before she knows where her car is going. In addition, as her car is an S reg Rover 400, I think that there is every possibility that it may be written off. I recall reading letters in your columns regarding some type of scam with courtesy cars. Is there anything that my sister should be wary of or avoid?

Asked on 30 January 2010 by D.M., Dronfield Woodhouse

Answered by Honest John
At 87, insurance may preclude the offer of a courtesy car. But if it is made they will offer her an 'equivalent' new car, probably at an excessive daily rental rate, while they take a long time sorting out whether to repair or write off her car. She will have to sign something that makes her liable for the rental if the other party's insurer refuses to pay. Actually, an S reg Rover 400 has virtually no value, maybe £500, so it should be written off straight away, with no delay.
Similar questions
I was involved in a car accident last year and the other party admitted liability. His insurance company rang and confirmed liability both to me and my insurers. My insurance duly paid for all the repairs...
I had a car accident over five years ago, the driver was convicted of dangerous driving. I had just bought the car and it was written off five minutes after leaving the garage. The garage had let me drive...
I was involved in an accident shortly before my insurance runs out. My current insurance has told me when my insurance runs out the courtesy car will be taken away unless my new insurance covers it. I...
Related models
Rover's version of the Honda Civic. Quite well equipped and a reasonable drive in its day.