What is life like with your car? Let us know and win £500 in John Lewis vouchers | No thanks

Thirst among equals

I own both a 2001 E320 CDI estate and a 2003 E320 CDI estate. The engines are ostensibly the same, the earlier one generating 194 bhp and the later one, 204. Fundamentally the later car gives significantly worse consumption than the earlier model overall but the difference is particularly large cruising at around 80 mph. At this sort of speed the later model shows consumption just under 35 mpg and older just under 40. It might be worth relating that on one occasion while the weather was very warm this summer (c30C), I achieved a figure closer to 40 mpg in the later car at around 80 mph. I know the later car is heavier but equally the aerodynamics are surely better and the engine fuel system a little more developed? The car is regularly serviced and I have already had the Air Flow Meter replaced which improved the consumption by a small margin (say 2 mpg). The fuel consumption is not terrible but given my mileage of more than 20,000 per year, the difference is getting toward £500. Your advice or assistance would be greatly appreciated.

Asked on 23 January 2010 by M.S., via e-mail

Answered by Honest John
No straightforward explanation except maybe fatter tyres. Later E320 CDIs with 224bhp 3.0 litre V6s (from October 2004) and diesel particulate filters were criticised for heavier consumption than straight six 320 CDIs because the engine has to periodically burn extra fuel to regenerate the filter
Similar questions
I own a 2009 Skoda Superb. It runs very well, done 110,000 miles and I plan to keep it. Skoda have invited me to bring it in for emission software change, assuring that there will be no change in fuel...
I do a 40 mile round trip every day with a mix of roads, including 70mph dual carriageway and a stretch of motorway for about 10 miles each way. Would a hybrid be suited to this driving? If no, I'm going...
I want to trade in my 2011 diesel Nissan X-Trail 2.2 for a slightly smaller 4WD. I commute 50 miles a day, but need a 4WD for rough farm tracks. I have a budget of about £20,000 - £25,000 after trading...