Should my sister-in-law buy a petrol or diesel Ford Focus for short journeys?

My sister-in-law is looking to purchase a new Ford Focus but cannot decide between the 1.6TDCI diesel and 1.6I petrol engines. She does less than 10,000 miles per year, mainly very short runs in town with little longer distance high speed (motorway) driving. I have advised that a diesel is not suitable, but others suggest that for economy and resale in five years a diesel would be better. Will economy for the diesel reach anything like the published mpg on short runs and will there really be a huge difference in resale for a Focus? What sort of damage will be done to a diesel with this sort of driving?

Asked on 16 August 2010 by edr

Answered by Honest John
A diesel is unsuitable for this sort of use, and economy is not brilliant when used just for short runs. Long runs 55mpg+. Short runs 35 - 40.
Similar questions
I'm a Motability hirer. For three years, I have driven a diesel Nissan Qashqai 1.5 and had no DPF problems whilst doing mainly short runs and covering 20,000 miles. My real mpg is approximately 45 - 60...
New Golf 1.4TSI petrol or new 1.6TDI diesel? I’ve done the maths. For both cars after three years at 8000 miles per year at urban mpg (43 petrol and 62 diesel) and local fuel prices I’ve calculated petrol...
I need an estate car with good reliability, and I want an automatic with reasonable economy. I have about £10,000 plus my trade-in. I am thinking of a used Passat, Mazda 6 or Volvo V70 and I know from...
Related models
Much improved 2004 Focus. Great to drive. Comfortable and well laid-out interior. Wide range of engines. Low emission ECOnetic versions offer 55mpg +.