Do runflat tyres normally shred within a few miles when being run at low pressure?

I recently had a bad experience with runflat tyres as a passenger in a friend's 2009 BMW 525 diesel. After the message saying 'check pressures', all tyres were inspected. All appeared okay with no obvious damage except one (the rear near-side) was warmer than the others. About a mile further on we tried to inflate the warm tyre but it would not hold air. So, having 25 miles to get home and with the handbook saying the tyre was good for 190km running flat with four (light) passengers we set off.

Most of the journey was easy, running through Leeds on a Sunday afternoon. There was no difficult terrain (steep hills or the like), but the tyre was completely shredded within 15 miles. Is this typical of the performance of runflat tyres? I also have them on my BMW 3 Series. Do you recommend buying a spacesaver and is there anything that can be done to preserve the operating life of the tyre whilst running flat? Can runflat tyres be replaced legally with conventional tyres?

Asked on 28 May 2010 by Peter

Answered by Dan Harrison
Not heard of those circumstances before, but there have been many complaints about runflat tyres in general. As for opting for conventional tyres, you may want to read this thread in the forum: www.honestjohn.co.uk/forum/post/index.htm?t=31334
Similar questions
My 2017 VW Golf GTE has 225/40-18 tyres which will soon need replacing. The Michelin Cross Climates are attractive and often recommended by you. However, the runflat version (Zero Pressure) only seems...
My wife's 2014 Mercedes C-Class Estate has non-runflats from factory (225/17/50). I would like to fit Michelin Crossclimate + ZP runflats, starting with 2 rear wheels then two fronts. Can I retro-fit...
I have a 2022 BMW 223i M Sport Active Tourer which came with non-run flat tyres fitted on BMW alloys. We suffered a puncture in a remote part of Scotland on holiday last week & the tyre repair kit was...