Free MOTs - beware!

I took advantage of a "Free MOT" with National Tyres and Auto Centres linked with an AA membership offer. A little sceptical as to how they financed this, but having taken my car to the main dealers for pads all round and front discs, National failed it on the MOT 4 weeks later for pitted and corroded rear discs.

A trip back to the main dealer and the MOT was granted - the rear discs they say should be good for another year or more and the pads are (obviously) fine. A "Free MOT" becomes very expensive if unscrupulous garages insist on unnecessary repairs. Is there a history of this sort of behaviour by National and other "players"?

Asked on 12 February 2013 by RMP

Answered by Honest John
Of course there is. But actually pitted rear discs are a legitimate fail.
Similar questions
I bought a used car online. The seller said he was a trader and the car was advertised as a part-exchange, just MoT'd with a one year warranty. I booked to view it (80 miles away) over the weekend at his...
My dad purchased me a 2009 MINI about two months ago, in which time I've done 2000 miles. When the car went for it's MoT, it passed with a minor refusal for headlight bulb but was advised an engine management...
My brother's Peugeot 206 was hit from behind by a bus, which dented the tailgate and smashed the back window. The damage was fairly minor and a new tailgate is all that's required to get it back on the...