Fuel consumption worse after using premium fuel.

A few months back I persuaded my wife that it was good practice and worthwhile to fill the Nissan X-Trail with higher quality diesel, as although it was more expensive it would be better for the car and offer better mpg.

At the time Total were offering a money back offer that if mpg wasnt improved they would refund your money. Ever since we filled up with Total Excellium diesel and our mpg has dropped from 37 to 34.

We have filled up many times since then with different fuels but cant get the mpg back up to 37 even on a long run. All I can think is the fuel was a bit dirty and has left some deposits on the injectors or something reducing the overall economy?

Asked on 1 July 2012 by Miles Gosling

Answered by Honest John
Heavier diesel can give better mpg, but eventually gums up the injectors. Try it on Shell V-Power diesel and see what happens. At this time of year, because of higher ambient temperatures, mpg should be getting better, not worse.
Similar questions
I wrote recently, and thank you for the reply, about my 2011 X-trail and the "flatness" around 2000rpm. My dealer says they all do it, something which I cannot believe and after much effort have now got...
I currently run a 2006 Honda Accord 2.2 i-CTDi and have been using Shell V-Power diesel fuel exclusively. I was just wondering what your thoughts are and why you singled out BP Ultimate diesel as your...
You often mention Shell V Power, BP ultimate, or Total as high quality fuel. Recently I have found Texaco have a 99 octane petrol which at least here in Dorset is only 8 pence per liter higher than the...
Related models
Excellent drive on tarmac and very competent off road, large boot, plenty of standard equipment.