Buying a Mercedes-Benz - petrol or diesel?

I am getting myself a little confused over the diesel/petrol debate. I realise that you need to do more mileage to benefit from diesel but did not realise that there were numerous items in the car which would require replacement regardless of miles travelled - shorter journeys indicate even quicker replacement of parts.

I have been looking at the Mercedes E-Class estate 250 CDI Blue Efficiency with auto gearbox (boot is bigger than the BMW 5 tourer, which I think you prefer) but normally only do short journeys during the week and longer at weekends - apart from holidays which can be long distances and high speeds.

Total mileage is normally 15 to 17,000 per year. I think you might advise petrol as per my current car but would welcome confirmation.

Also is it still possible to obtain discounts for Mercedes-Benz from dealerships as margins must be tighter due to the Euro/GBP exchange rate problems.

Drive the Deal still offers what I consider a very good discounted price and from your previous comments you have no problems with them at all.

Asked on 20 February 2012 by DavidT1

Answered by Honest John
Drive The Deal remains the best and most reliable broker.

I don't receive a lot of complaints of Mercedes diesel DPF failures, and an autobox means you won't have DMF problems. 15k - 17k miles a year should make diesel worthwhile.
Similar questions
I need a 4x4 with a high seating position but only cover about 8000 miles a year. I have been offered a good deal on a BMW X1 20d. Do BMWs have the same DPF probs as others as I intend keeping it for three...
Should I be choosing petrol or diesel for central London bearing in mind the the proposed levy on diesels. My short list is Merc GLE, Lexus RX 450h, landrover discovery, BMW x5/x3 but last three diesel...
Need new car to replace Peugeot 207SW 1.6 Sport Got two Volkswagen Golfs to choose from, a 100 mile pre-reg GT estate diesel (150) for £20k with 3 yrs free servicing OR a brand new GT estate with 150...
Related models
Huge and useful boot space. Well-built and solid interior. Comfortable long distance cruiser. Excellent diesels. Very refined.